Re: [Vo]:Bard chatbot released
Robin wrote: > When they stuff something up, you might consider asking for the reference > they used to provide the wrong answer. > Yes, that is a good technique. I have used that successfully with ChatGPT.
Re: [Vo]:Bard chatbot released
In reply to Jed Rothwell's message of Thu, 23 Mar 2023 10:59:18 -0400: Hi, An exam is largely a test of knowledge, and chatbots get to cheat by accessing reference material. However a real lawyer also needs to have a deep understanding of human beings and their motivations, and also to be creative. I doubt a chatbot would be so good at that. Cloud storage:- Unsafe, Slow, Expensive ...pick any three.
Re: [Vo]:Bard chatbot released
In reply to Jed Rothwell's message of Thu, 23 Mar 2023 10:59:18 -0400: Hi Jed, When they stuff something up, you might consider asking for the reference they used to provide the wrong answer. That gives humans a chance to fix the original, which will in turn result in better future responses. >H L V wrote: > > >> However, the second part of the statement is not accurate. Oxygen-18 is a >>> heavier isotope of oxygen with two more neutrons and two more protons in >>> its nucleus, not one more neutron and one more proton. >>> >> >> If it had two more protons it would be neon. >> > >You are right. I didn't even read the response carefully. It is funny that >Bard got it right the second time and ChatGPT messed up. > >This shows you need to check these responses carefully. The chatbots are >far from reliable now. They are improving rapidly. > >Despite the problems, the latest version of ChatGPT reportedly passed a bar >exam that it previously failed. See: > >https://www.abajournal.com/web/article/latest-version-of-chatgpt-aces-the-bar-exam-with-score-in-90th-percentile Cloud storage:- Unsafe, Slow, Expensive ...pick any three.
Re: [Vo]:Bard chatbot released
H L V wrote: > However, the second part of the statement is not accurate. Oxygen-18 is a >> heavier isotope of oxygen with two more neutrons and two more protons in >> its nucleus, not one more neutron and one more proton. >> > > If it had two more protons it would be neon. > You are right. I didn't even read the response carefully. It is funny that Bard got it right the second time and ChatGPT messed up. This shows you need to check these responses carefully. The chatbots are far from reliable now. They are improving rapidly. Despite the problems, the latest version of ChatGPT reportedly passed a bar exam that it previously failed. See: https://www.abajournal.com/web/article/latest-version-of-chatgpt-aces-the-bar-exam-with-score-in-90th-percentile
[Vo]:Holey Magnetosphere
https://www.sciencealert.com/nasa-is-tracking-a-huge-growing-anomaly-in-earths-magnetic-field
Re: [Vo]:Bard chatbot released
On Thu, Mar 23, 2023 at 9:26 AM Jed Rothwell wrote: > ChatGPT found and corrected the mistake made by Bard. > > > ME: Is the following statement correct, and if not, what is the correct > version? "Deuterium is a heavier isotope of hydrogen with one more neutron > in its nucleus, while oxygen-18 is a heavier isotope of oxygen with one > more neutron and one more proton in its nucleus." > > ChatGPT: The first part of the statement is correct. Deuterium is a > heavier isotope of hydrogen with one more neutron in its nucleus. > > However, the second part of the statement is not accurate. Oxygen-18 is a > heavier isotope of oxygen with two more neutrons and two more protons in > its nucleus, not one more neutron and one more proton. > If it had two more protons it would be neon. harry
Re: [Vo]:Bard chatbot released
Bard also got it right when I asked about the statement in isolation. This shows that the output from these programs is inconsistent. ME: Is the following statement correct, and if not, what is the correct version? "Deuterium is a heavier isotope of hydrogen with one more neutron in its nucleus, while oxygen-18 is a heavier isotope of oxygen with one more neutron and one more proton in its nucleus." Bard: The statement is not correct. Deuterium is a heavier isotope of hydrogen with one more neutron in its nucleus. Oxygen-18 is a heavier isotope of oxygen with two more neutrons in its nucleus. Deuterium (D) has one neutron and one proton in its nucleus, while protium (H) has no neutrons and one proton. Oxygen-18 (O-18) has eight neutrons and ten protons, while oxygen-16 (O-16) has eight neutrons and eight protons.
Re: [Vo]:Bard chatbot released
ChatGPT found and corrected the mistake made by Bard. ME: Is the following statement correct, and if not, what is the correct version? "Deuterium is a heavier isotope of hydrogen with one more neutron in its nucleus, while oxygen-18 is a heavier isotope of oxygen with one more neutron and one more proton in its nucleus." ChatGPT: The first part of the statement is correct. Deuterium is a heavier isotope of hydrogen with one more neutron in its nucleus. However, the second part of the statement is not accurate. Oxygen-18 is a heavier isotope of oxygen with two more neutrons and two more protons in its nucleus, not one more neutron and one more proton.
