[Vo]: Which is electrolyzed in PF, palladium or heavy water? (was Re: [Vo]: Re: Your ad hominem attack)

2007-03-19 Thread Michel Jullian
No decomposition is not the only definition. Electroplating is also considered electrolysis. If by this you mean that electroplating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroplating is not electrical decomposition you are quite mistaken Ed, it is. What decomposes in electroplating is --as in any

Re: [Vo]: Which is electrolyzed in PF, palladium or heavy water? (was Re: [Vo]: Re: Your ad hominem attack)

2007-03-19 Thread Terry Blanton
On 3/19/07, Michel Jullian [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: (sorry for being such a smug aristocratic French smart ass Terry) (You should have placed a comma after 'smug', 'aristrocratic' and 'ass'.) I understand it is your nature. You can no more help it than a frog striking his ass every time he

Re: [Vo]: Which is electrolyzed in PF, palladium or heavy water? (was Re: [Vo]: Re: Your ad hominem attack)

2007-03-19 Thread Edmund Storms
Michel Jullian wrote: No decomposition is not the only definition. Electroplating is also considered electrolysis. If by this you mean that electroplating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroplating is not electrical decomposition you are quite mistaken Ed, it is. What decomposes in

Re: [Vo]: Which is electrolyzed in PF, palladium or heavy water? (was Re: [Vo]: Re: Your ad hominem attack)

2007-03-19 Thread Michel Jullian
So, this complex process you just described, whereby Li plates on and reacts with the Pd to form soluble alloys, these dissolve and the Pd is replated back on the cathode surface --- which indeed involves decomposition and electric current flowing through a solution, just like electrolysis! ---

Re: [Vo]: Which is electrolyzed in PF, palladium or heavy water? (was Re: [Vo]: Re: Your ad hominem attack)

2007-03-19 Thread Edmund Storms
Michel Jullian wrote: So, this complex process you just described, whereby Li plates on and reacts with the Pd to form soluble alloys, these dissolve and the Pd is replated back on the cathode surface --- which indeed involves decomposition and electric current flowing through a solution,

Re: [Vo]: Which is electrolyzed in PF, palladium or heavy water? (was Re: [Vo]: Re: Your ad hominem attack)

2007-03-19 Thread Philip Winestone
Ed - I've been following this saga only sketchily, and it only reinforces my observation that there's an enormous number of people who regard this world as a gigantic court of law; that everything (every word) has to be legally justifiable. What a bore The world is NOT like that, and I

Re: [Vo]: Which is electrolyzed in PF, palladium or heavy water? (was Re: [Vo]: Re: Your ad hominem attack)

2007-03-19 Thread Michel Jullian
No Ed, I didn't find it interesting to show that the words electrolysis and electrolyzed were misused, the painful exchange on this very unininteresting point should have lasted no more than a handful of lines. As you know it was you who made this discussion last for ages, deliberately making