[Vo]:Gas flow to Arata cell NOT shut off

2008-06-06 Thread Jed Rothwell
In my first report on the Arata experiment, I made a mistake that upset Takahashi to no end. The captions in Fig. 2 and Fig. 4 that I sent here (both English and Japanese) say D+-jet stream stopped. Based on this, plus the fact that gas loading stops abruptly, I assumed that the valve was

Re: [Vo]:Gas flow to Arata cell NOT shut off

2008-06-06 Thread Edmund Storms
The statement made by Dr. Wang about D filling voids in the Pd lattice is based on an assumption, for which no experimental evidence exists in the literature as far as I know. A person has to be very careful to separate such assumptions from what is actually known, based on good work.

Re: [Vo]:Gas flow to Arata cell NOT shut off

2008-06-06 Thread Jed Rothwell
Edmund Storms wrote: The statement made by Dr. Wang about D filling voids in the Pd lattice is based on an assumption, for which no experimental evidence exists in the literature as far as I know. Yup. Some researchers in this field have a bad habit of mixing speculation with statements