Lewis Larsen (Lattice Energy LLC) has posted a response to the recent criticism of W-L theory by Ciuchi, et al, on Arxiv.org. See -
"Response to Sept 2012 Univ of Rome arXiv Preprint-Oct 30 2012" http://www.slideshare.net/lewisglarsen/lattice-energy-llc-response-to-sept-2012-univ-of-rome-arxiv-preprintoct-30-2012-14956399
