Re: [webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread Allison Newman
Hi Brent, Sure. The goal of the debugger API is to allow client apps to create their own Javascript debugger as part of their browser. This isn't possible at the moment because the API is private, and hence you need to build the debugger code as part of Webkit to be able to access the header

Re: [webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread Brent Fulgham
Hi Alli, On Tue, Jun 14, 2011 at 7:38 AM, demallien wrote: > I'm interested in providing a public C API for accessing debugger > functionality in JavascriptCore. Can you share the goals of this external API, and why the existing inspector infrastructure is not sufficient? Maybe if we better und

Re: [webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread Adam Barth
demallien, My sense from Oliver's response is that there aren't any plans to start this process. He's one of the key decision makers on this topic and he sounds pretty negative about creating such an API. Generally, the WebKit project tries to be careful about creating public APIs because they c

Re: [webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread demallien
 WebKit-Dev Development On 14 Jun, 2011,at 06:30 PM, demallien wrote:Yup, that sounds pretty "official" to me :)In which case, are there any plans to start this process?  _javascript_Core has been around for quite a while now, and this is a relatively important piece of technology to have for a de

Re: [webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread Oliver Hunt
It depends on what you mean by "official" I would probably r- any patch that attempted to create such an API, but it's conceivable that a sensible API could be made that masked the current craziness sufficiently to allow the craziness to be removed later. But any API would need to be very care

Re: [webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread demallien
Is that an official response?On 14 Jun, 2011,at 06:03 PM, Oliver Hunt wrote:The current debugging mechanism is not particularly pleasant to use, nor is it very future proof, it has significant performance costs, and it requires the user to have significant knowledge of the inner workings of JSC.

Re: [webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread Oliver Hunt
The current debugging mechanism is not particularly pleasant to use, nor is it very future proof, it has significant performance costs, and it requires the user to have significant knowledge of the inner workings of JSC. Before we started considering exposing JS debugging through API (and theref

[webkit-dev] Public APIs for accessing the Javascript debugger

2011-06-14 Thread demallien
Hi,I'm interested in providing a public C API for accessing debugger functionality in _javascript_Core.  Ideally I would like the code to be merged into webkit, so I wanted to know if there is a policy reason for not already having debugger APIs available in the public _javascript_Core APIs?  If so