Re: [whatwg] Sequential List Proposal

2007-04-17 Thread Michel Fortin
Le 2007-04-17 à 13:05, Kristof Zelechovski a écrit : Methinks we could easily overcome the semantic problems with the dialogue element if we renamed it to transcript. The problem I described is not about the meaning of dialog, it's about structuring its content to accomodate various uses.

Re: [whatwg] Sequential List Proposal

2007-04-11 Thread Kevin Marks
On 4/10/07, Benjamin Hawkes-Lewis [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Kevin Marks wrote: I think the dialog example is a retrograde step. The olliciteq|blockquote pattern seems much better than redefining dt and dd, which will confuse XOXO parsers that try to be Postelian. Did I miss some reasoning

Re: [whatwg] Sequential List Proposal

2007-04-11 Thread Benjamin Hawkes-Lewis
On Wed, 2007-04-11 at 11:13 -0700, Kevin Marks wrote: My point is that this is breaking the expected containment of dtdd in a dl- if you want a new structure purely for dialog, define speaker and keep q. I really fail to see why redefining a definition list as speech is less 'proper' than

Re: [whatwg] Sequential List Proposal

2007-04-10 Thread Kevin Marks
On 4/8/07, Elliotte Harold [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Michel Fortin wrote: So I propose a sl element (sequential list) which can be used to replace dialog as well as other things. The proposal can be found here: Sounds a little redundant with ol (ordered list). Also sounds needlessly

Re: [whatwg] Sequential List Proposal

2007-04-10 Thread Benjamin Hawkes-Lewis
Kevin Marks wrote: I think the dialog example is a retrograde step. The olliciteq|blockquote pattern seems much better than redefining dt and dd, which will confuse XOXO parsers that try to be Postelian. Did I miss some reasoning here? Fictional dialogs don't involve the excerpt and citation

Re: [whatwg] Sequential List Proposal

2007-04-05 Thread Michel Fortin
Le 2007-04-05 à 10:36, Simon Pieters a écrit : I get a 404 for this URI. Oops... sorry. http://www.michelf.com/documents/whatwg/sequential-list/ Michel Fortin [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.michelf.com/