Re: [whatwg] do not encourage use of small element for legal text (was: Pre-Last Call Comments)

2009-06-05 Thread Giovanni Campagna
2009/6/5 Jeff Walden jwalden+wha...@mit.edu: Do you seriously believe any client in an industry where he has to step carefully enough to worry about typographical formatting of legal notices is fool enough to follow a not-even-recommendation in the HTML5 specification over what his lawyer

[whatwg] do not encourage use of small element for legal text (was: Pre-Last Call Comments)

2009-06-04 Thread Andrew W. Hagen
Responding to Kristof Zelechovski. I have a copy of the Constitution of the United States on my web site. That is a legal text. It also qualifies as legalese, a derogatory term. If I were to change it to HTML 5, the current spec encourages me to place the entire Constitution in small elements.

Re: [whatwg] do not encourage use of small element for legal text (was: Pre-Last Call Comments)

2009-06-04 Thread Křištof Želechovski
While I actually defended the recommendation to use the SMALL element for legal text, and I am still ready to do it, it is worth noting that the text of section 4.6.6. does not contain such a recommendation. It merely states that out of possible uses of the SMALL element, the legal use is the

Re: [whatwg] do not encourage use of small element for legal text (was: Pre-Last Call Comments)

2009-06-04 Thread Jeff Walden
Do you seriously believe any client in an industry where he has to step carefully enough to worry about typographical formatting of legal notices is fool enough to follow a not-even-recommendation in the HTML5 specification over what his lawyer tells him is the correct thing to do? Jeff