Re: [Wien] berryphase

2013-12-09 Thread Oleg Rubel
Dear Shahrbano, Do you think that the intermediate is necessary? By transition I meant transition between lambda0 as the centrosymmetric phase and lambda1 as the noncentrosymmetic phase. You do not have to calculate intermediate structures, but Eq. (2) in Phys. Rev. B, 1993, 47, 1651-1654

[Wien] berryphase

2013-12-06 Thread Shahrbano Raheme
Dear Prof. Rubel and Sheikh, Are there total or partial forces? What are the values? Oops! It was partial force that was large:  :FOR002:   2.ATOM          6.892          0.000          0.000          6.892 partial forces Then, I performed one more iteration by adding -fc flag to my run to

Re: [Wien] berryphase

2013-12-05 Thread Oleg Rubel
Dear Shahrbano, ... Although we could reproduce the SP of the sample, P_s= P_z(lambda1)- P_z(lambda0) = 0.312113863793- 1.52399256575e-11 = 0.31211386360 C/m^2 which is very close to the readme file (but not exactly the same as it P_s= P_z(lambda1)- P_z(lambda0)=

Re: [Wien] berryphase

2013-12-05 Thread Sheikh Jamil Ahmed
Hello Shahrbano, I also agree with Dr. Rubel that this fraction of discrepancy that you are getting is probably due to the fact we made this tutorial on Wien2k version 11.0. Regarding the forces for optimizing the structure, I always try to optimize my structure to a much lower value (0.2

[Wien] berryphase

2013-12-04 Thread Shahrbano Raheme
Dear Prof. Rubel, A quick glance at these references shows that they are discussing zinc blende structure as a zero-polarization reference. So you probably need to make a zinc blende GaN is the same fashion as wurtzite structure. Fig. 12 in [Physics Reports, Volume 428, Issue 1, May 2006,

Re: [Wien] berryphase

2013-12-01 Thread Oleg Rubel
Dear Shahrbano ... But, we still do not know what is the role of * in tmp=$(grep lapw1 *-c $SEEDNAME.dayfile). As far as I know –c flag is necessary when inversion symmetry is break down and complex calculations are needed to be performed by the WIEN2k code. I am not aware about *-c flag.

[Wien] berryphase

2013-11-30 Thread Shahrbano Raheme
Dear Prof. Rubel, and Sheikh,   it's good to hear that everything worked with the fresh install. I am  also interested to trace the origin of your previous problems, but I  cannot reproduce the error. If you still have an access to the previous  installation and can reproduce both correct and

Re: [Wien] berryphase

2013-11-28 Thread Oleg Rubel
Dear Shahrbano, it's good to hear that everything worked with the fresh install. I am also interested to trace the origin of your previous problems, but I cannot reproduce the error. If you still have an access to the previous installation and can reproduce both correct and incorrect results,

[Wien] berryphase

2013-11-27 Thread Shahrbano Raheme
Dear Prof. Rubel and Prof. Sheikh, 1) Take the structure files enclosed (I assume they are not different from yours). I used your stature file and found that it is identical to my structure. Please, make sure that you have the latest version of WIEN2WANNIER (see the post 

Re: [Wien] berryphase

2013-11-27 Thread Sheikh Jamil Ahmed
Hello Shahrbano, If check the refereed post you find the following about the compatibility issue of WIEN2k v12 or later with WIEN2WANNIER v0.96 or older We came across a minor compatibility issue between WIEN2WANNIER and a newer version