Re: [Wien] spin-orbit (PBE and mBJ) for perovskites

2019-12-09 Thread Peter Blaha
Don't go above EMAX=10 for SO calculations with RLOs. On 12/9/19 9:32 PM, Mikhail Nestoklon wrote: Dear Prof. Blaha, Thank you for clarification. I think, now I more or less understand what is happening. It seems, this issue is very easy to miss. Do you have any practical recommendation how

Re: [Wien] Band structure calculation

2019-12-09 Thread Gavin Abo
1. The empty error files should be normal [1,2].  The generated empty error files are needed by the program so it can determine if something killed the executable or not [3]. 2. The "LAPW1 - Error" by itself is insufficient.  You need additional error information such as an INILPW message

Re: [Wien] spin-orbit (PBE and mBJ) for perovskites

2019-12-09 Thread Mikhail Nestoklon
Dear Prof. Blaha, Thank you for clarification. I think, now I more or less understand what is happening.  It seems, this issue is very easy to miss. Do you have any practical recommendation how to spot this kind of problem in the calculations of non-trivial material with few atoms?   Sincerely

[Wien] error in elastic constants

2019-12-09 Thread prasad jayasena
Dear wien2k community I wanted to get the elastic constants of a cubic structure using elastic module in wien2k. I completed the calculation I am getting unacceptable values as below in GPa: c11= -36037.828466 c12=18133.340459 c44= 54.083125 I used the optimized correct structure

Re: [Wien] spin-orbit (PBE and mBJ) for perovskites

2019-12-09 Thread Peter Blaha
Hi, Fist of all: The RLOs (p-1/2)-LOs were originally designed to improve the SO splitting of semicore states. There it makes a big difference and is essential to converge E-tot in a meaningful way. (By meaningful I do not mean the absolute number as you tested it, but an E-tot difference

Re: [Wien] spin-orbit (PBE and mBJ) for perovskites

2019-12-09 Thread Mikhail Nestoklon
Dear Dr. Tran, Thank you for the suggestion. Indeed, for CsPbCl3 I get very similar values (0.70 for PBE-SO and 1.67eV for TB-mBJ) and if I add RLO on Pb for CsPbI3 at least for PBE-SO I have something close to value given in Jishi.   However, now I have a general question. How to understand

[Wien] Band structure calculation

2019-12-09 Thread Santanu Pathak
In an calculation with PBE xc, energy values are coming without any warning and the error files are generating but are completely empty. Whereas band structure calculation is being interrupted due to lapw1 error, shown in follow. LAPW1 - Error 0.140u 0.015s 0:00.15 100.0%0+0k 0+5136io