[Wiki-research-l] New issue of Human Computation, open-access journal

2015-08-13 Thread Flöck , Fabian
Attached is the announcement and table of contents of a new issue of the open-access journal Human Computation. No Wikipedia-themed papers this time, but maybe certain articles are still interesting to some on this list. Gruß, Fabian Human Computation – A Transdisciplinary Journal

Re: [Wiki-research-l] identity disclosure hurt the reliability of review systems, but not necessarily efforts provision

2015-08-13 Thread Kerry Raymond
Did the paper look at the other side of the coin where an anonymous reviewer uses their dislike of someone to give them a poorer score than they deserved? From the description of the experiment, I assume none of the participants knew one another before the experiment and so could not have

Re: [Wiki-research-l] identity disclosure hurt the reliability of review systems, but not necessarily efforts provision

2015-08-13 Thread Kevin G Crowston
Subject: Wiki-research-l Digest, Vol 120, Issue 16 Can someone who has access to that paper please share the method and results as fair use? Here are a few key paragraphs from the methods and results section. Method We test two “social conditions” Anonymous vs. Identity disclosure (

Re: [Wiki-research-l] identity disclosure hurt the reliability of review systems, but not necessarily efforts provision

2015-08-13 Thread James Salsman
Kerry Raymond wrote: ... we could use big data to try to pro-actively find patterns of undesirable behaviour I agree, including with the specific examples given, most if not all of which could be implemented within a general accuracy review system. Please consider the three-level (actually

Re: [Wiki-research-l] identity disclosure hurt the reliability of review systems, but not necessarily efforts provision

2015-08-13 Thread Kerry Raymond
Well, we could take a leaf out of the enemy's playbook and advertise on Freelancer (and similar sites) for someone to do paid reviewing of Wikipedia edits. Given the healthy trade on those sites seeking people to write Wikipedia articles (often including phrases like and ensure it is not