[Wikisource-l] About texts without supporting files and Index: pages

2013-06-10 Thread David Cuenca
With the deployment of Wikidata it is a good moment to re-examine what Index pages are and what should be their function. The most direct transition to a Wikidata-supported Wikisource could be something like this: https://sites.google.com/site/dacuetu/BookData.pdf That would allow: - to share

Re: [Wikisource-l] About texts without supporting files and Index: pages

2013-06-10 Thread David Cuenca
@Alex: but what do you think of storing the source information in Index: pages for all works stored in Wikisource, even if they don't have a supporting scan? That was the original question :) About your proposed library, it would be more useful if it could modify data in Wikidata, not only

Re: [Wikisource-l] About texts without supporting files and Index: pages

2013-06-10 Thread Alex Brollo
Simply there is no need to store data twice or more, if they are dinamically imported from wikidata. Such data would be simply generated by a normal template. Something similar to Commons media sharing: most wikipedians but beginners know that when you want to edit a shared media file, you must do

Re: [Wikisource-l] About texts without supporting files and Index: pages

2013-06-10 Thread David Cuenca
No, it won't be stored in Wikisource, but still there is the need to present the information in a consistent manner. If you want to display the information on ns0, you will end up needing the same fields that the Index: page is using now. So why not to have the same solution for both? It could

Re: [Wikisource-l] About texts without supporting files and Index: pages

2013-06-10 Thread Alex Brollo
I'm going to test what you are telling in a real Lua script; as you know, Lua can read the code of any page with one expensive server function only, so that a simple {{header|index name}} ns0 template call could read all the wiki code from index page, parse it, extract all its data content, and