Re: Question about MTU and Wireguard and the current changes

2022-01-10 Thread tlhackque

On 10-Jan-22 15:37, henning.re...@gmail.com wrote:

Hi,
I run in some connection troubles between two wireguards host (one 
running fedora 35, one arch linux). If I tried to transfer large files 
through SSH (SCP or btrfs send/receive thorugh ssh through wireguard 
tunnel) it stucks after a few byte and nothing transfered anymore.


This happens in the last days, so probably an update on one or both 
machines. I also saw, that there some changes on the MTU thing (If I 
remember correctly, a per peer MTU is configurable)


However. My first try was just set the MTU to a lower number (MTU = 
1200) and yes, scp works again.
Okay, so I did the good old ping test. "ping -M do -s $SIZE -c 1 
172.16.0.2" with $SIZE increasing. And that surprised me. It works 
until an Size of 36932 Bytes. Checked with wireguard and "MTU = 36932" 
and yes, scp still working.


Can somebody explain, why the old default setting of "65456" doesn't 
work anymore but the MTU can set to much higher values as typical ones?


Thanks
Henning

Guess: Fragmentation happens somewhere and fragments are blocked at your 
router/firewall/host.  Blocking fragments is a common, if misguided, 
"security enhancement".


A packet trace would provide the necessary clues in any case.

Wireshark is a convenient way to get one.



OpenPGP_signature
Description: OpenPGP digital signature


Question about MTU and Wireguard and the current changes

2022-01-10 Thread henning . reich

Hi,
I run in some connection troubles between two wireguards host (one 
running fedora 35, one arch linux). If I tried to transfer large files 
through SSH (SCP or btrfs send/receive thorugh ssh through wireguard 
tunnel) it stucks after a few byte and nothing transfered anymore.


This happens in the last days, so probably an update on one or both 
machines. I also saw, that there some changes on the MTU thing (If I 
remember correctly, a per peer MTU is configurable)


However. My first try was just set the MTU to a lower number (MTU = 
1200) and yes, scp works again.
Okay, so I did the good old ping test. "ping -M do -s $SIZE -c 1 
172.16.0.2" with $SIZE increasing. And that surprised me. It works until 
an Size of 36932 Bytes. Checked with wireguard and "MTU = 36932" and 
yes, scp still working.


Can somebody explain, why the old default setting of "65456" doesn't 
work anymore but the MTU can set to much higher values as typical ones?


Thanks
Henning