Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-12-03 Thread John Thomas
They can do either depending on configuration John Richard Munoz wrote: I thought that these switches would deny the Source MAC Address instead of disabling the entire port. -Richard M. A little more info would be good. If they want to authenticate everyone, then 802.1x switches are

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-12-01 Thread Tom DeReggi
John, The concern for PPPOE is wether client sessions will re-establish automatically after disconnects of the link. For example, if a Pre-n BElkin router is used for a end user link, and I did connect there service, for example by rebooting a trango AP at the cell site or from significant

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-12-01 Thread Butch Evans
On Wed, 30 Nov 2005, John Scrivner wrote: complete report on the incident and a plan for how I will prevent people from doing this in the future at all locations. I am thinking we can use PPPoE to force all users even on the hardwired network to authenticate in order to get on the Internet.

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-12-01 Thread Butch Evans
On Wed, 30 Nov 2005, Lonnie Nunweiler wrote: doing anything. HotSpot and PPPoE require that you have a radius server. Not necessarily. Some implementations, this is true, but not all. (FWIW, the radius server DOES make management easier.) -- Butch Evans BPS Networks

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-12-01 Thread Richard Munoz
I thought that these switches would deny the Source MAC Address instead of disabling the entire port. -Richard M. A little more info would be good. If they want to authenticate everyone, then 802.1x switches are available-if you don't authenticate, your port turns off. If they just want to

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-11-30 Thread Scott Reed
How did connecting a laptop circumvent how they access the Internet?  Sounds to me like the government entity does not restrict access to the Internet, they restrict what a PC can get to on the PC.  Seems like a bad approach.  How about a good ole proxy server that requires authentication to

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-11-30 Thread Marlon K. Schafer (509) 982-2181
Our local school uses something that does what you are asking for the kids. Check with your school. If that doesn't work I can get you the name and number for who to ask here. I'm pretty sure it's done via some kind of security server. Nothing so complicated as pppoe. BTW, I think that

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-11-30 Thread Lonnie Nunweiler
PPPoE will break things like printers. I would use a HotSpot style authentication and enable only the known machines. All other machines are sent to a login page or are simply firewalled and prevented from doing anything. HotSpot and PPPoE require that you have a radius server. Lonnie On

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-11-30 Thread Jory Privett
I do not really understand what you are trying to accomplish but I do PPPoE for my network. I have used it in a few other cases. It is fairly easy to setup and should not limit anything on a windows network. Call me if I can be of help Jory Privett WCCS 940.683.5797 - Original Message

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-11-30 Thread David E. Smith
John Scrivner wrote: Anyone out there have experience with PPPoE?. [ snip ] Based on the scenario you've described, PPPoE may not be the best solution. It'll probably break a lot of Windows-specific stuff (printer and file sharing leap to mind). Those could be worked around with a

Re: [WISPA] Ethernet based authentication

2005-11-30 Thread John Thomas
John Scrivner wrote: Anyone out there have experience with PPPoE?. I have a client who is a local government entity. They have people who have abused their Internet connection in the past. They restrict who has Internet access and when it can be used. One of our techs unknowingly circumvented