Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Scott Reed
From MDK's original post this is what I saw as a plan of action that I could agree to: 1) Develop and follow a statement in regards as to how WISPA will address all frequency space. Whether it be autcion it all, make it all available, make it all license-lite, something else may not be as

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Faisal Imtiaz
I am going to address your points backwards:- You wrote --- And lastly, about the FCC, the last administration's appointees were advocates for free markets and for competition and deregulation. Not particularly effective ones, but at least they were not our enemy. The current

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Faisal Imtiaz
Here .. incase you all don't follow the Telecom Side of Regulatory events.. Here is what happens with 'Deregulation'... http://radinfo.blogspot.com/2011/07/florida-psc-bill.html Get ready for the new Robber Barrons of the 21's century... The ILEC's of the USA. This marks the beginning of a

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Mike Hammett
Your first point is why I've been beating the dead horse of getting people to avoid the telcos wherever possible. - Mike Hammett Intelligent Computing Solutions http://www.ics-il.com On 7/16/2011 9:42 AM, Faisal Imtiaz wrote: I am going to address your points backwards:- You

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Forbes Mercy
I'm sorry I guess I missed you at the Legislative Committee list when I was putting this together sending out drafts and asking for comments and help /sarcasm. WISPA is a representation of those who show up to help formulate consensus and policy, not my personal views. So easy to throw darts

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread RickG
+1 On Sat, Jul 16, 2011 at 6:58 AM, Scott Reed sr...@nwwnet.net wrote: From MDK's original post this is what I saw as a plan of action that I could agree to: 1) Develop and follow a statement in regards as to how WISPA will address all frequency space. Whether it be autcion it all, make

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread RickG
it is Regulation (1996 Telecom Act) that allowed us (ISP's) to be able to go into the business of providing internet access and other communication services With all due respect, it's exactly the mindset that government allows us to be in business that IS the problem. Telecom Act or no,

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Faisal Imtiaz
Well...again you have to go further back in history...before telecom regulation ..it was a Ma Bell monopoly ..and without regulation...there is a very good chance that it will again become a Ma Bell monopoly or maybe a duopoly... Let's not forget that... Faisal On Jul 16, 2011, at 9:03

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Scott Reed
I also noticed that the breakup of Ma Bell degraded service in many areas. A monopoly by market demand is not necessarily bad. A monopoly by regulation is bad. On 7/16/2011 9:25 PM, Faisal Imtiaz wrote: Well...again you have to go further back in history...before telecom regulation ..it was

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Fred Goldstein
At 7/16/2011 09:41 PM, Scott Reed wrote: I also noticed that the breakup of Ma Bell degraded service in many areas. A monopoly by market demand is not necessarily bad. A monopoly by regulation is bad. Well, not necessarily. Ma Bell's service was never consistent before the breakup, but

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Greg Ihnen
Faisal, If I understand history correctly, there was a time when the country was best served by a monopoly. In it's infancy fierce competition wouldn't have led to a strong nationwide phone system. But then times changed and the country was best served by the divestiture (breakup) of

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread Curtis Maurand
On 7/15/2011 9:03 AM, Forbes Mercy wrote: Forbes Mercy WISPA VP/Legislative Chair Just to give you an idea of what you're up against, the #1 provider of lobbying money and political donations to congress is the healthcare industry. They are followed by the telecom industry. --Curtis Maurand

Re: [WISPA] The Legislative Situation Is Dire

2011-07-16 Thread RickG
And that's not regulation, that's bribery and corruption! Maybe we need to regulate the regualtors?!?! On Sat, Jul 16, 2011 at 11:20 PM, Curtis Maurand cmaur...@xyonet.comwrote: On 7/15/2011 9:03 AM, Forbes Mercy wrote: Forbes Mercy WISPA VP/Legislative Chair Just to give you an idea of