[WISPA] Can WiMAX Challenge 3G?

2006-11-29 Thread Dawn DiPietro

Can WiMAX Challenge 3G?
29th November , 2006

US : WiMAX has gained significant momentum over the last year. Its 
standardization is complete, vendor and operator ecosystems are 
expanding, and the hype is getting louder, often justifiably so.


Inset shows the result of asking the participants  Has your business 
considered investing in WiMax.  

In this report, we move beyond the hype and theoretical discussion; we 
look at real-world examples of pre-WiMAX deployments and review 
practical issues such as time-to-market, business models and pricing, 
device availability, economics of scale and spectrum availability, with 
an emphasis on a number of key questions, most notably, can WiMAX 
challenge 3G?


The answer will eventually be determined by the operator community, so 
we surveyed about 100 operators to tune into their views, investments 
plans, expectations and concerns in respect to WiMAX. With 78 percent of 
the surveyed operators considering an investment in WiMAX, we believe 
the promise of WiMAX is compelling and the technology warrants further 
examination.


The result is an in-depth, case-study based analysis about the viability 
of WiMAX, and the potential threat it poses to 3G. We include over 20 
pages of specific market forecasts, case studies, analyses of 
competitive landscapes by region, and overview of current deployments. 
Finally, we include a regionalized breakdown of operators' responses to 
23 questions about their plans for WiMAX.


Key Questions Answered
Does mobile WiMAX perform better than 3G?
Will mobile WiMAX be cheaper than 3G?
How will mobile WiMAX IPR affect the 3G value proposition?
Which players have the best case for deploying mobile WiMAX?
What is the current operator perception of mobile WiMAX? What do 
operators believe is the primary driver for its success? The largest 
obstacle?
Where are the most attractive opportunities for mobile WiMAX? How will 
spectrum availability, licensing procedures, market competition, and 
technology time-to-market impact certain markets?
What is the size of the WiMAX opportunity in key sample markets (France, 
India, Mexico and the US)?


More details here http://www.pyramidresearch.com/

Link to see inset graphic.
http://www.3g.co.uk/PR/Nov2006/3984.htm
--
WISPA Wireless List: wireless@wispa.org

Subscribe/Unsubscribe:
http://lists.wispa.org/mailman/listinfo/wireless

Archives: http://lists.wispa.org/pipermail/wireless/


Re: [WISPA] Can WiMAX Challenge 3G?

2006-11-29 Thread Tom DeReggi
The fear that I have about WiMax is that as it is deployed for mobile, it 
will start to cause a negative impact on branding that previously helped the 
industry.


Publization of the word WiMax, helped WISPs gain validity and visibility 
for offering next generation RELIABLE SCALABLE fixed broadband services.
I could say Security/ Reliability concerns you have? We don't deploy Wifi, 
we use carrier grade equipment, sorta like WiMax, you know that 
technology/hype  that you've probably read about in the newspaper 
recently..


Now with WiMAXe (Mobility), carriers will start to brand it as a mobile 
solution, and use it for best effort service offerings to every laptop, 
which surely will degrade wide scale reliabilty potential of the solution 
(Bypassing engineering process of Fixed Installations by professionals).


It almost necessary to promote a NEW word to define our industry, before 
WiMax reputation/branding gets destroyed or distorted in publ;ic 
perception. Actually customer perception will not be distorted because most 
WiMax equipment will be mobile, it just means the word will end up not 
meaning what we do as Fixed carriers.  WiMax will mean what ever the 
dominent use for the technology is.  I wish they would have branded it 
WiMax Mobile.  Now maybe we need to brand it Fixed WiMax.  Using the 
double connotation, that not only is it stationary, but we make it work 
(fixed it).


How does this apply to this thread... Everytime WiMax gets written about 
cvomparing it to Cellular mobile solutions, it strengthens perception that 
WiMax is mobile.


Tom DeReggi
RapidDSL  Wireless, Inc
IntAirNet- Fixed Wireless Broadband


- Original Message - 
From: Dawn DiPietro [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To: WISPA General List wireless@wispa.org
Sent: Wednesday, November 29, 2006 6:55 AM
Subject: [WISPA] Can WiMAX Challenge 3G?



Can WiMAX Challenge 3G?
29th November , 2006

US : WiMAX has gained significant momentum over the last year. Its 
standardization is complete, vendor and operator ecosystems are expanding, 
and the hype is getting louder, often justifiably so.


Inset shows the result of asking the participants  Has your business 
considered investing in WiMax.
In this report, we move beyond the hype and theoretical discussion; we 
look at real-world examples of pre-WiMAX deployments and review practical 
issues such as time-to-market, business models and pricing, device 
availability, economics of scale and spectrum availability, with an 
emphasis on a number of key questions, most notably, can WiMAX challenge 
3G?


The answer will eventually be determined by the operator community, so we 
surveyed about 100 operators to tune into their views, investments plans, 
expectations and concerns in respect to WiMAX. With 78 percent of the 
surveyed operators considering an investment in WiMAX, we believe the 
promise of WiMAX is compelling and the technology warrants further 
examination.


The result is an in-depth, case-study based analysis about the viability 
of WiMAX, and the potential threat it poses to 3G. We include over 20 
pages of specific market forecasts, case studies, analyses of competitive 
landscapes by region, and overview of current deployments. Finally, we 
include a regionalized breakdown of operators' responses to 23 questions 
about their plans for WiMAX.


Key Questions Answered
Does mobile WiMAX perform better than 3G?
Will mobile WiMAX be cheaper than 3G?
How will mobile WiMAX IPR affect the 3G value proposition?
Which players have the best case for deploying mobile WiMAX?
What is the current operator perception of mobile WiMAX? What do operators 
believe is the primary driver for its success? The largest obstacle?
Where are the most attractive opportunities for mobile WiMAX? How will 
spectrum availability, licensing procedures, market competition, and 
technology time-to-market impact certain markets?
What is the size of the WiMAX opportunity in key sample markets (France, 
India, Mexico and the US)?


More details here http://www.pyramidresearch.com/

Link to see inset graphic.
http://www.3g.co.uk/PR/Nov2006/3984.htm
--
WISPA Wireless List: wireless@wispa.org

Subscribe/Unsubscribe:
http://lists.wispa.org/mailman/listinfo/wireless

Archives: http://lists.wispa.org/pipermail/wireless/ 


--
WISPA Wireless List: wireless@wispa.org

Subscribe/Unsubscribe:
http://lists.wispa.org/mailman/listinfo/wireless

Archives: http://lists.wispa.org/pipermail/wireless/