Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-24 Thread Ian Anderson
Justin Owens wrote: * the img alt text read 'logo' but the link went to home Your alt attribute should be modified to correctly represent the actual image. IMHO, 'logo' is not descriptive enough to be used as alternative text for a linked image. In my opinion, it is important for linked

RE: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-24 Thread Patrick Lauke
Ian Anderson To consider two extreme examples if the MSNBC logo was linked to the home page, alt text of MSNBC would be the least helpful, although that is the exact equivalent of what happens visually for sighted users, and they then use their acquired knowledge to understand that it links

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-24 Thread Ian Anderson
Patrick Lauke wrote: How about a dual approach of using ALT that describes the image (MSNBC) and a title on the link to provide additional advisory information of where the link is going to ('MSNBC home page'), i.e. Great minds and all that? If you reread the previous bit of my post you'll

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-24 Thread Darren West
It definatly should, relax and think of home ;-) On 23/02/06, John S. Britsios [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dear co-members, I would like to ask your opinion here, if a web site logo should or not link to the homepage. By the way, see for example what Jesper Tverskov wrote about this:

RE: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-24 Thread Patrick Lauke
Ian Anderson Great minds and all that? If you reread the previous bit of my post you'll see: 'So, the logo should say something like MSNBC home page' Yes, but you seemed to suggest having that as the ALT, whereas I'd say it's more appropriate to just have MSNBC as the ALT and have the

RE: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Caleb Evans
I think it should. I think people are used to clicking on a logo to return to the home page and if you are going to make the logo a link - the standard location for it is home. I guess it could link through to Information about the Company or individual but I don't think this is the norm. I

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Christian Montoya
On 2/23/06, Caleb Evans [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I think it should. I think people are used to clicking on a logo to return to the home page and if you are going to make the logo a link - the standard location for it is home. I think we can make this a design pattern. One thing that helps is

RE: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Herrod, Lisa
Linking back to the Home page via a logo placed top-left is one of those design conventions/patterns that users of various experience appear to be learning. I haven't seen novice users navigating this way, but certainly users with moderate computer/internet literacy are. However, I don't agree

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Serdar Kılıç
For me it seems very natural to have it link back to home, but I would also like to see an explicit link in the navigation to take me home as well. On 23/02/06, John S. Britsios [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dear co-members, I would like to ask your opinion here, if a web site logo should or not

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Jay Gilmore
Herrod, Lisa wrote: Christian, can you point us to an example where home text has been added to the logo on site sub-pages? I'm really interested to see the type of sites that are implementing this. Lisa, This idea appears on page 63 and then discussed on page 67 of Steve Krug's, Don't

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Justin Owens
John: We have had a few small projects where we did not link back to home via the logo. In each of the usability tests, the users overwhelmingly tried clicking on the logo to return home and were very frustrated when the could not click. So, based from practical usability experience, I am going

RE: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Herrod, Lisa
Message- From: Justin Owens [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, 24 February 2006 9:59 AM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage? John: We have had a few small projects where we did not link back to home via the logo. In each

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Sandra Vassallo
of functionality and I can't think of a reason why you wouldn't implement it. lisa -Original Message- From: Justin Owens [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, 24 February 2006 9:59 AM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage? John: We have

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Mark Harris
Sandra Vassallo wrote: Hi, interestingly, one of my testers who uses a screen reader recently suggested taking the link off the logo in the head mast and the reasons made sense * the img alt text read 'logo' but the link went to home * there was already a clear text link to home on the site,

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Justin Owens
* the img alt text read 'logo' but the link went to home Your alt attribute should be modified to correctly represent the actual image. IMHO, 'logo' is not descriptive enough to be used as alternative text for a linked image. I view it much the same as using 'picture' on a photo. You are not

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Sandra Vassallo
Actually the alt text was descriptive on the test site, I just used 'logo' for the example. However, the description had the same problems I mentioned. The link also added to the verbosity when read aloud by JAWS. Justin Owens wrote: * the img alt text read 'logo' but the link went to home

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread Sandra Vassallo
Hi Mark, I agree accessibility and usability go hand in hand. However, changing the alt text (it was actually descriptive on the test site) still means the link descriptions are different. I simply mentioned it as an example of a situation where the linked image wasn't working well from a

Re: [WSG] Should logo not link to the homepage?

2006-02-23 Thread heretic
I would like to ask your opinion here, if a web site logo should or not link to the homepage. Anecdotally, I've seen a lot of users who do click the logo - especially if it's placed at the top left of the page. It's not a standard, but it's a common design element which many users pick up very