[WSG] Confusing the users...

2006-02-21 Thread Geoff Pack
Jason Turnbull wrote: Terrence Wood wrote: Jakob Nielsen responded to my request for clarification Jacob has used this request for his latest article http://www.useit.com/alertbox/within_page_links.html Regards Jason Ignoring the discussion of in-page links and jumping straight

Re: [WSG] Confusing the users...

2006-02-21 Thread Gunlaug Sørtun
Geoff Pack wrote: If the users don't understand a particular feature of the web, one that's been around since its very beginning, then they (damn well) should feel insecure in their mastery. They are not masters (yet). If we don't confuse the users occaissionly, how will they ever learn that

RE: [WSG] Confusing the users... In Page Links

2006-02-21 Thread Herrod, Lisa
This is really interesting article in that it contradicts findings of a recent study we completed just 2 weeks ago. We recently conducted user testing on a site with 22 participants, which is a significant sample (often we test with 8 to 12). The demographic was 18 skilled workers and 4

Re: [WSG] Confusing the users... In Page Links

2006-02-21 Thread Mike Brown
Herrod, Lisa wrote: This is really interesting article in that it contradicts findings of a recent study we completed just 2 weeks ago. We recently conducted user testing on a site with 22 participants, which is a significant sample (often we test with 8 to 12). The demographic was 18 skilled

RE: [WSG] Confusing the users... In Page Links

2006-02-21 Thread Herrod, Lisa
users, just wanted to clarify that point. Anyway, I'll leave it at that. All this talking is giving me a hoarse throat... -Original Message- From: Mike Brown [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, 22 February 2006 1:28 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] Confusing

RE: [WSG] Confusing the users... In Page Links

2006-02-21 Thread Paul Bennett
] Confusing the users... In Page Links Herrod, Lisa wrote: This is really interesting article in that it contradicts findings of a recent study we completed just 2 weeks ago. We recently conducted user testing on a site with 22 participants, which is a significant sample (often we test with 8

Re: [WSG] Confusing the users...

2006-02-21 Thread heretic
Or do we just dumb everything down until we have some small subset that everyone understands? I've often found the Nielsen goes too far - beyond make it more usable, through to make it more stupid or even cater to such a low common denominator that average users actually start to get

Re: [WSG] Confusing the users...

2006-02-21 Thread Terrence Wood
Jason Turnbull: Terrence Wood wrote: Jakob Nielsen responded to my request for clarification Jacob has used this request for his latest article http://www.useit.com/alertbox/within_page_links.html Wow! there's my 15 seconds of fame. If he'd mentioned me by name I'd be immortal! The other