Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-29 Thread Tom Livingston
On Thu, 25 Aug 2005 00:13:16 -0400, tee [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi accessible care takers, In light of this recent discussion, I offer this, if you haven't already read it (or already know this info): http://www.useit.com/alertbox/open_new_windows.html -- Tom Livingston Senior

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-26 Thread Thierry Koblentz
Janelle Clemens wrote: Thank you all for explaining the use of target=top.I will be discussing this with my manager and hopefully we will start implementing target=_blank. A late side note regarding the use of the target attribute. I believe some blockers do *not* let the browser spawn a

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Felix Miata
tee wrote: Hi accessible care takers, I know open new window even for external site is no good and have put it in practise for most sites I have done, however I am kind of stuck on a site that has over 100 links to external sites. My client, understands no accessible issues however she

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Jackie Reid
@webstandardsgroup.org Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2005 2:13 PM Subject: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma Hi accessible care takers, I know open new window even for external site is no good and have put it in practise for most sites I have done, however I am kind of stuck on a site that has over 100

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread designer
Hi Tee, All I can say is that, as a sighted viewer, if I encountered a site with 100 links, each of which which opened in the same window, I'd be outa there faster than you can say 'back button' :-) I've been wondering of late if there is another way out of this: just like we can change

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Vicki Berry
Hi Tee, Why not say in the text of the page, opens in new browser window in parentheses after the link? (If it's a pdf or other file type, state that here as well, together with the file size.) The WCAG says you should warn people and in *most* cases adding in the warning works well. A lot of

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Patrick Lauke
Vicki Berry Why not say in the text of the page, opens in new browser window in parentheses after the link? I'd say not *after* the link, but *as part of* the link. If a user is tabbing between links, they will not get to the text after the link itself.

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Vicki Berry
Patrick Lauke wrote: I'd say not *after* the link, but *as part of* the link. If a user is tabbing between links, they will not get to the text after the link itself. Good point, Patrick! Thanks. Vicki. :-) -- Vicki Berry DistinctiveWeb Web: http://www.distinctiveweb.com.au Blog:

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Thierry Koblentz
tee wrote: done, however I am kind of stuck on a site that has over 100 links to external sites. My client, understands no accessible issues however she was willing to take many of my suggestions, except the NO 'open new window' to external sites. Her argument is valid and justifiable, that

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Drake, Ted C.
: http://www.superiorpixels.com/portfolio.html Ted -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of designer Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2005 1:39 AM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma Hi Tee, All I can say

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Paul Novitski
At 01:39 AM 8/25/2005, designer wrote: All I can say is that, as a sighted viewer, if I encountered a site with 100 links, each of which which opened in the same window, I'd be outa there faster than you can say 'back button' :-) I've been wondering of late if there is another way out of

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Janelle Clemens
] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of tee Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2005 9:13 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma Hi accessible care takers, I know open new window even for external site is no good and have put it in practise for most sites I have

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Drake, Ted C.
Hi Janelle Regardless of your window philosophy, I think using target=top is asking for trouble. That is a common target for pages with frames. I would at least suggest using a target name that is not part of the frame architecture. That is why most people used target=_blank. There are better

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread designer
Hi Paul, You're right of course: I do that too. However, I really do think that most folk don't know about right-clicking in the way you describe, so it's not so much a case of choosing as knowing that you can. I suppose one could always put that option clearly as a line of text, viz: To

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Paul Novitski
At 11:00 AM 8/25/2005, Janelle Clemens wrote: Who says opening a new window is bad practice. Especially if it is an outside link. I've been searching the web for information on this and finding nothing. My understanding of web accessibility and 508 is to make everything as clear a possible.

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Ben Curtis
On Aug 25, 2005, at 11:24 AM, Drake, Ted C. wrote: Regardless of your window philosophy, I think using target=top is asking for trouble. That is a common target for pages with frames. I would at least suggest using a target name that is not part of the frame architecture. That is why

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Thierry Koblentz
Jackie Reid wrote: a href=http://www.siteurl.com.au; title=Opens in a New Window onclick=window.open(this.href); return false; onkeypress=window.open(this.href); return false;External link here/a this is detailed in the juicy studio article here

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Thierry Koblentz
Ben Curtis wrote: 1- link replaces current document (no target or js new window) 2- link always opens new window (target=_blank or js equivalent with unnamed window, e.g., window.open(this.href,'',winOptions);) I agree, the opener getting focus each time the user clicks on a link create

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Janelle Clemens
@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma At 11:00 AM 8/25/2005, Janelle Clemens wrote: Who says opening a new window is bad practice. Especially if it is an outside link. I've been searching the web for information on this and finding nothing. My understanding

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Patrick H. Lauke
Janelle Clemens wrote: Does the reader not read the title tag which states Link will open in a new browser window.?I thought that is why we use the title tag to give more info on the link. Not always. Depends on verbosity settings of screen readers, which in many cases don't have that

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Ben Curtis
On Aug 25, 2005, at 12:33 PM, Thierry Koblentz wrote: Ben Curtis wrote: 1- link replaces current document (no target or js new window) 2- link always opens new window (target=_blank or js equivalent with unnamed window, e.g., window.open(this.href,'',winOptions);) I agree, the opener

RE: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread Janelle Clemens
.I feel like everything right now is a theory. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Patrick H. Lauke Sent: Thursday, August 25, 2005 1:14 PM To: wsg@webstandardsgroup.org Subject: Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma Janelle

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread tee
Hi everyone, thank you for the feedback, I greatly appreciate. Sorry for the slow response but I want to gather as many feedback as possible, then absorb it, so that I can present a better approach for my client. Terrence, thanks for the suggestion. I am going to ask my client for her

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-25 Thread David Hucklesby
Hi Tee, Sorry about the delay. I am behind on my emails. :-) Should you decide to use Thierry's solution, there's a variant in Sitepoint's new book you may like. It adds a checkbox so the surfer can choose the behavior they want. It is described in Chapter three as Creating Smarter Links.

[WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-24 Thread tee
Hi accessible care takers, I know open new window even for external site is no good and have put it in practise for most sites I have done, however I am kind of stuck on a site that has over 100 links to external sites. My client, understands no accessible issues however she was willing

Re: [WSG] another 'open new window' dilemma

2005-08-24 Thread Terrence Wood
You can suggest some user testing and run an A/B test (no new windows/new windows) on the same design and see what the actual user preference is instead of relying on assumptions. Alternatively, you could provide a prefernce link somewhere on the page that set's a cookie and writes the page