Re: [wtp-dev] XML Language Server based on WTP?

2018-03-14 Thread Angelo zerr
Hi Mickael, > What is the general user-story here? Provide an advanced XML Language Server. > Do you want to work on creating XML edition-assist in other IDEs than Eclipse IDE? I'm thinking (but I don't know if I will have time) to move my Angular Eclipse (which uses already tm4e) to lsp4e

[wtp-dev] XML Language Server based on WTP?

2018-03-14 Thread Angelo zerr
HI all, I tell me if we could develop an XML Language Server which uses the WTP IDOMDocument to provode a language server to benefit with completion, hover, etc like JDT https://github.com/eclipse/eclipse.jdt.ls/ does. What do you think about this idea? Regard's Angelo

Re: [wtp-dev] XML Language Server based on WTP?

2018-03-14 Thread Gorkem Ercan
I think a proper XML LSP with features comparable to WTP XML editing is missing. WTP as the base for that LSP is too resource hungry especially for something like XML and complicated (also incomplete in places). I actually have a prototype XML LSP sitting somewhere. It is not complete, it

Re: [wtp-dev] XML Language Server based on WTP?

2018-03-14 Thread Angelo zerr
> What does XML TextMate grammar brings that's missing in WTP/XML ? I would like to have the same look than other HTML, CSS, TypeScript editor based on tm4e/lsp4e. 2018-03-14 14:46 GMT+01:00 Mickael Istria : > > > On Wed, Mar 14, 2018 at 2:38 PM, Angelo zerr

Re: [wtp-dev] XML Language Server based on WTP?

2018-03-14 Thread Mickael Istria
I think it's a good idea. That said, it's a big piece of work to make a LS on top of WTP. Moreoever, this LS would be pretty huge (we're talking about probably a hundred MB to bring WTP XML as a LS), so it may not easily fit in VSCode Marketplace. JDT-LS had to workaround it with a relatively