Re: xml-apis dependency

2008-04-16 Thread Tatu Saloranta
--- Bradley Wagner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Thanks for the quick response. If I understand you > correctly, xml-apis > is an improvement rather than a true requirement > when running with > Java 5.0. > > All of the interfaces, classes that are implemented > or subclassed by > Xalan are

Re: xml-apis dependency

2008-04-16 Thread Bradley Wagner
The xml-apis I have came bundled with JBoss 3.2.7 (admittedly ancient) and uses the JAXP 1.2 spec as per the JAR's manifest file. I don't see an org.w3c.dom.xpath package in either my 1.5 JRE classes or this xml-apis JAR. I do see a org.w3c.dom.xpath package in my Xalan 2.6 JAR but those in

Re: xml-apis dependency

2008-04-16 Thread Michael Glavassevich
Now that I think of it there are several APIs (org.w3c.dom.xpath for example) bundled in xml-apis.jar which are not included in the JAXP 1.3 specification (and by extension Java 5) that Xerces and Xalan depend on. Sun may have shipped them but there's no guarantee that they'll be there. Thanks. M

Re: xml-apis dependency

2008-04-16 Thread Bradley Wagner
Thanks for the quick response. If I understand you correctly, xml-apis is an improvement rather than a true requirement when running with Java 5.0. All of the interfaces, classes that are implemented or subclassed by Xalan are available with Java 5 so I would not run into any class loadin

Re: xml-apis dependency

2008-04-16 Thread Michael Glavassevich
Hi Bradley, xml-apis.jar contains bug fixes (and even performance improvements) [1] which may not be in Java 5 so you may be trading these off by not carrying the jar with your application. Thanks. [1] http://xml.apache.org/commons/changes.html#version_xml-commons-external-1.3.04 Michael Glavas