Re: [fdo] xorg-xf86-input-keyboard license

2019-10-29 Thread Adam Jackson
On Sun, 2019-10-27 at 09:37 -0700, Alan Coopersmith wrote: > We should probably delete lnx_kbd.c, both to give license clarity and to stop > people from thinking it's a useful driver to have on Linux systems any more. > > If you're building the X server for a Linux box you want either the

Re: [fdo] xorg-xf86-input-keyboard license

2019-10-27 Thread Alan DuBoff
On Sun, October 27, 2019 9:37 am, Alan Coopersmith wrote: > Why do you care about the server license if you're writing an application > (i.e. a client)? Not the OP, but I will tell you why it is important. GPL, as you know, is put in place to protect the opensource aspect of the code, and as such

Re: [fdo] xorg-xf86-input-keyboard license

2019-10-27 Thread Alan DuBoff
On Sun, 27 Oct 2019, Alan Coopersmith wrote: GPL does not require clients to follow the licensing conditions of servers they connect to. In regard to this point, I will just point out that I advocate the use of GPL as a form of protection, and the input drivers should fall into that

Re: [fdo] xorg-xf86-input-keyboard license

2019-10-27 Thread Alan DuBoff
On Sun, 27 Oct 2019, Alan Coopersmith wrote: You explained the GPL, which I well understand, but not why someone working on client software cares about the license of something on the server side. GPL does not require clients to follow the licensing conditions of servers they connect to. Why

Re: [fdo] xorg-xf86-input-keyboard license

2019-10-27 Thread Alan Coopersmith
On 10/27/19 10:07 AM, Alan DuBoff wrote: On Sun, October 27, 2019 9:37 am, Alan Coopersmith wrote: Why do you care about the server license if you're writing an application (i.e. a client)? Not the OP, but I will tell you why it is important. You explained the GPL, which I well understand,

Re: [fdo] xorg-xf86-input-keyboard license

2019-10-27 Thread Alan Coopersmith
[I've cc'ed the xorg mailing list, where this is a much more on-topic question than the freedesktop general mailing list.] On 10/27/19 6:12 AM, 布施 博明 wrote: Hello I am developing X application now I have one question about xorg-xf86-input-keyboard license Why do you care about the server