Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Bruno Benitez
I think I agree with Pjotr when he says that not having any game will make the distro look more dry, less friendly. Not all the people who would choose xubuntu to install on machines will have internet conections constantly, some might go to places where its just an easy to install and use OS for

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Ince, Wilbur
Games DO take space on the ISO, which is a premium. So removing them should be a consideration. Advanced users will not miss them, because they will install their own anyway. NEW users are the prize target here. Not including them makes the distro seem cheap and flimsy as was pointed out. Is

RE: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Thomas Molloy
The basics are a nice thing to have, especially when you're on a slow connection during setup so you can play minesweeper while things download. Tho not really needed beyond that so I would +1 removing them as well. - Thomas MolloyLderan Date: Wed, 28 Jan 2015 03:58:42 -0600 Subject: Re:

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Pasi Lallinaho
I would drop all games altogether. I don't know how many play simple desktop games in 2015, but I would imagine its a lesser number than browser-based game players. Ultimately, it's definitely less than people who use social media... That being said, I'm sure people will rather log in to

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Dave
I would agree, that only one or two of the existing games. (First thing I do is install the games I actually use). This may get me shot down :-) , but how about including the steam installer undergame with just one or two games.. Dave On 28 January 2015 at 08:08 Jackson Doak

User Type Poll

2015-01-28 Thread Elfy
There is an agenda item on User Polls. We're trying to find out how users identify themselves, this is a first step in that direction. There's an etherpad set up with the current thoughts. [1] Comments on that please [1] http://pad.ubuntu.com/xubuntu-user-identifies-as -- xubuntu-devel

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Frostsongr
Depends on the gamer really. I play rare indie games to triple A games on linux using many sources including steam and wine if I can't get it to work natively in Linux. Most people just want it to work though. As far as an OS you should not worry too much about gaming really. Just have the basics.

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread David Pires
+1 from me on dropping the games altogether. The majority of today gamers are mostly into emulators, console and social media platforms games. slickymaster https://wiki.ubuntu.com/slickymaster Xubuntu Documentation Lead -- xubuntu-devel mailing list xubuntu-devel@lists.ubuntu.com

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Dave
Very Good point on teh Licencing of Steam forgot about that.. In that case, I will change my mind and go for dropping the games.. virtually everyone i know who uses Xubuntu (or any linux distro) install the game they want and very rarely use the one already installed. Regards Dave On 28

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread PK
I would like to plea for having some simple games by default in Xubuntu Most simple Xubuntu users I know (people with little understanding of computers, who use Xubuntu because somebody installed Xubuntu for them), make use of those simple games rather frequently. They play mostly AisleRiot,

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Lutz Andersohn
Agreed, we don't need games I think. Sent from Blue Mail On Jan 28, 2015, 2:09 AM, at 2:09 AM, Jackson Doak nosk...@ubuntu.com wrote: I think having some default games is important, but we don't need more that minesweeper + 1 other On 28 Jan 2015 18:55, Elfy ub.u...@btinternet.com wrote:

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Jackson Doak
I think having some default games is important, but we don't need more that minesweeper + 1 other On 28 Jan 2015 18:55, Elfy ub.u...@btinternet.com wrote: Discussion started on the subject of removing games from the install at the last meeting, taking this to the list for more comments. --

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Bruno Augusto Clemente de Assis
I think we should keep at least one or two games. Cut them off wouldn't be nice. Still there is people who play games in desktop, i'm one of them, although not frequently. +1 to (Solitaire, Minesweeper, Chess) they are extremely useful when your internet is off or you are waiting for someone.

Re: Discussion: Default office applications

2015-01-28 Thread Pasi Lallinaho
On 2015-01-28 23:32, Peter Rauhut wrote: Is it crucial to have a default office application at all? I would imagine anybody who is new to Linux would be happy just having access to Mousepad as a GUI text editor in the menu Mousepad is the equivalent of Notepad in Windows. People can probably

Re: Discussion: Default office applications

2015-01-28 Thread Jackson Doak
We need to triage the current lp abiword bugs, as a lot was fixed in 3.0.1. Maybe watching the svn could help too, as the upstream devs are fairly active We are one bugfix release behind on gnumeric, so if anyone's reasoning is a bug, can they please check

Re: Discussion: Default office applications

2015-01-28 Thread Pasi Lallinaho
On 2015-01-28 22:51, George DiceGeorge wrote: Would you have to put all components of LibreOffice in the ISO, including the dictionaries, or could you just put the word processer part in the ISO and a link to download the rest of it? [george] How are we feeling about our default

Discussion: Default office applications

2015-01-28 Thread Elizabeth K. Joseph
Hi everyone, We've had this discussion a few times in past cycles, but as we continue to bump into bugs in Abiword[0], the topic has come up again. How are we feeling about our default choice of Abiword and Gnumeric as the office applications for Xubuntu? Is it time to consider switching to

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Elizabeth K. Joseph
On Wed, Jan 28, 2015 at 6:54 AM, Peter Rauhut dab...@gmail.com wrote: What is the premium for the games? I don't know off the top of my head how much space they take up, but the VM install of Xubuntu 14.04 I'm looking at right now only came with Mines and Sudoku, I can't imagine those are much

Re: Discussion: Default office applications

2015-01-28 Thread George DiceGeorge
Would you have to put all components of LibreOffice in the ISO, including the dictionaries, or could you just put the word processer part in the ISO and a link to download the rest of it? [george] How are we feeling about our default choice of Abiword and Gnumeric as the office

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread George DiceGeorge
can i vote to include sokoban if its not too big as its the only game i play, ive had 3 year olds play it successfully! [george] -Original Message- From: Elizabeth K. Joseph Sent: Wednesday, 28 January, 2015 20:36 To: Xubuntu Development Discussion Subject: Re: Installed Games On

Re: Discussion: Default office applications

2015-01-28 Thread Eero Tamminen
Hi, On keskiviikko 28 tammikuu 2015, Elizabeth K. Joseph wrote: We've had this discussion a few times in past cycles, but as we continue to bump into bugs in Abiword[0], the topic has come up again. How are we feeling about our default choice of Abiword and Gnumeric as the office

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread David Bermúdez Guiot
OK, first of all, sorry for the shortness of my contribution. Allow me to explain a bit. We are thinking about standard on the go users who run Xubuntu Live, I think GiMP is a great tool for editing and creating photo projects. But games, lets be truly sinceres, we dont run it live to play, am I

Re: Discussion: Default office applications

2015-01-28 Thread Elfy
On 28/01/15 20:39, Jackson Doak wrote: We need to triage the current lp abiword bugs, as a lot was fixed in 3.0.1. Maybe watching the svn could help too, as the upstream devs are fairly active We are one bugfix release behind on gnumeric, so if anyone's reasoning is a bug, can they please

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Pasi Lallinaho
On 2015-01-29 01:40, Bruno Benitez wrote: I think that the basic use of an image editor for a standard user are the ones signaled on the tables on the comparison page [1], Croping, Adding text, Rezise, Rotate, Navigate Folders. The only thing a good image viewer still lacks on linux is adding

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Bruno Benitez
I think that the basic use of an image editor for a standard user are the ones signaled on the tables on the comparison page [1], Croping, Adding text, Rezise, Rotate, Navigate Folders. The only thing a good image viewer still lacks on linux is adding text, thats the only thing from the list that

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Dave Dodge
On Wed, Jan 28, 2015 at 11:17:46AM +0200, Pasi Lallinaho wrote: shipping Steam isn't sensible with any distribution. Only the amount of data we would need to ship with every download is beyond insanity – just to install a few games the user might or might not play once, let alone talking about

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Peter Rauhut
What is the premium for the games? I don't know off the top of my head how much space they take up, but the VM install of Xubuntu 14.04 I'm looking at right now only came with Mines and Sudoku, I can't imagine those are much larger than a few MBs. That's a very small impact on the size of the

Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Pasi Lallinaho
Since we are discussing about other choices in the default seed already, it feels like the perfect time to bring yet another discussion to the table: Do we want to keep shipping GIMP? For some background, the team has discussed the issue [1] and gone through various simpler alternatives [2]

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Jackson Doak
I'd prefer we dropped gimp, it's a bit too big and complex for the default install. maybe a lighter editor would be nice though. On Thu, Jan 29, 2015 at 9:29 AM, Pasi Lallinaho p...@shimmerproject.org wrote: Since we are discussing about other choices in the default seed already, it feels like

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Eero Tamminen
Hi, On torstai 29 tammikuu 2015, David Bermúdez Guiot wrote: Gimp should still be shipped, however I don't think games should be installed. Why? What's your reasoning? Btw. Is it possible to have Software Center front page seeded with things that people may want to install first (things

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Peter Rauhut
Agreed. The learning curve is too steep for a default editor. If there isn't a good replacement for a default editor, it should be dropped. On Jan 28, 2015 4:37 PM, Jackson Doak nosk...@ubuntu.com wrote: I'd prefer we dropped gimp, it's a bit too big and complex for the default install. maybe a

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Erik OShea
SuperTux 2 is also a great game and SuperTuxKart Both are amazing. On Wed, Jan 28, 2015 at 3:42 PM, George DiceGeorge dicegeo...@hotmail.com wrote: can i vote to include sokoban if its not too big as its the only game i play, ive had 3 year olds play it successfully! [george]

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Erik OShea
Gimp is really not that bad it is a bit heavy. i use it all the time on xubuntu 14.10 on my desktop and ubuntu mate 14.10 on my external hard drive. its definitely not for the beginner user. On Wed, Jan 28, 2015 at 5:29 PM, Pasi Lallinaho p...@shimmerproject.org wrote: Since we are discussing

Re: Discussion: GIMP in the default seed

2015-01-28 Thread Erik OShea
There is also a portable version you can run on a external hard drive. windows takes a bit longer deepening if you have ssd or hdd. On Wed, Jan 28, 2015 at 8:47 PM, Erik OShea erikoshe...@gmail.com wrote: Gimp is really not that bad it is a bit heavy. i use it all the time on xubuntu 14.10

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread Elfy
On 28/01/15 07:54, Elfy wrote: Discussion started on the subject of removing games from the install at the last meeting, taking this to the list for more comments. Just a bit confused as to how this apparently says Can we have a list of all the games each of you would like to see cluttering up

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread A Blesius
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 I agree with Pjotr and Bruno, was just about to answer in the same way. Some basic games (and I think we're not talking about 2–3 here) don't hurt too much, but none at all makes Xubuntu like a boring distro, which can't be rescued by cool wallpapers

Re: Installed Games

2015-01-28 Thread XbrandoX
Everyone I know who isn't a developer looks for the standard windows 98 games when they get stuck on my linux machines ... minesweeper solitaire. Not sure if that's worth anything, though. On 01/28/2015 11:33 AM, Bruno Augusto Clemente de Assis wrote: I think we should keep at least one or