Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-13 Thread David Dyer-Bennet
On Tue, September 7, 2010 15:58, Craig Stevenson wrote: 3. Should I consider using dedup if my server has only 8Gb of RAM? Or, will that not be enough to hold the DDT? In which case, should I add L2ARC / ZIL or am I better to just skip using dedup on a home file server? I would not

Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-08 Thread Roy Sigurd Karlsbakk
3. Should I consider using dedup if my server has only 8Gb of RAM? Or, will that not be enough to hold the DDT? In which case, should I add L2ARC / ZIL or am I better to just skip using dedup on a home file server? As Cindy said, skip dedup for now. It's not stable (enough). Try to destroy a

Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-08 Thread Darren J Moffat
On 08/09/2010 00:41, Scott Meilicke wrote: Craig, 3. I do not think you will get much dedupe on video, music and photos. I would not bother. If you really wanted to know at some later stage, you could create a new file system, enable dedupe, and copy your data (or a subset) into it just to

[zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-07 Thread Craig Stevenson
I am working on a home file server. After reading a wide range of blogs and forums, I have a few questions that are still not clear to me 1. Is there a benefit in having quad core CPU (e.g. Athlon II X4 vs X2)? All of the web blogs seem to suggest using lower-wattage dual core CPUs. But;

Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-07 Thread Cindy Swearingen
Craig, I'm sure the other home file server users will comment on your gear and any possible benefit of a L2ARC or separate log device... Use the default checksum which is fletcher4, I fixed the tuning guide reference, skip dedup for now. Keep things as simple as possible. Thanks, Cindy On

Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-07 Thread Russ Price
On 09/07/2010 03:58 PM, Craig Stevenson wrote: I am working on a home file server. After reading a wide range of blogs and forums, I have a few questions that are still not clear to me 1. Is there a benefit in having quad core CPU (e.g. Athlon II X4 vs X2)? All of the web blogs seem to

Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-07 Thread Eric D. Mudama
On Tue, Sep 7 at 17:13, Russ Price wrote: On 09/07/2010 03:58 PM, Craig Stevenson wrote: I am working on a home file server. After reading a wide range of blogs and forums, I have a few questions that are still not clear to me 1. Is there a benefit in having quad core CPU (e.g. Athlon

Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-07 Thread Scott Meilicke
Craig, 3. I do not think you will get much dedupe on video, music and photos. I would not bother. If you really wanted to know at some later stage, you could create a new file system, enable dedupe, and copy your data (or a subset) into it just to see. In my experience there is a significant

Re: [zfs-discuss] Configuration questions for Home File Server (CPU cores, dedup, checksum)?

2010-09-07 Thread Russ Price
On 09/07/2010 05:58 PM, Eric D. Mudama wrote: How are you measuring using 60% across all four cores? I kicked off a scrub just to see, and we're scrubbing at 200MB/s (2 vdevs) and the CPU is 94% idle, 6% kernel, 0% IOWAIT. zpool-tank is using 3.2% CPU as shown by 'ps aux | grep tank'