Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread Brandon High
On Tue, Jun 8, 2010 at 10:51 AM, BJ Quinn bjqu...@seidal.com wrote: 3.  Take a snapshot on the new server and call it the same thing as the snapshot that I copied the data from (i.e. datap...@nightly20090715) It won't work, because the two snapshots are different. It doesn't matter if they

Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread BJ Quinn
Is there any way to merge them back together? I really need the history data going back as far as possible, and I'd like to be able to access it from the same place . I mean, worst case scenario, I could rsync the contents of each snapshot to the new filesystem and take a snapshot for each

Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread Scott Meilicke
You might bring over all of your old data and snaps, then clone that into a new volume. Bring your recent stuff into the clone. Since the clone only updates blocks that are different than the underlying snap, you may see a significant storage savings. Two clones could even be made - one for

Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread Brandon High
On Tue, Jun 8, 2010 at 12:52 PM, BJ Quinn bjqu...@seidal.com wrote: Is there any way to merge them back together?  I really need the history data going back as far as possible, and I'd like to be able to access it from the same place .  I mean, worst case scenario, I could rsync the contents

Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread BJ Quinn
Not exactly sure how to do what you're recommending -- are you suggesting I go ahead with using rsync to bring in each snapshot, but to bring it into to a clone of the old set of snapshots? Is there another way to bring my recent stuff in to the clone? If so, then as for the storage savings,

Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread BJ Quinn
Ugh, yeah, I've learned by now that you always want at least that one snapshot in common to keep the continuity in the dataset. Wouldn't I be able to recreate effectively the same thing by rsync'ing over each snapshot one by one? It may take a while, and I'd have to use the --inplace and

Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread Brandon High
On Tue, Jun 8, 2010 at 4:29 PM, BJ Quinn bjqu...@seidal.com wrote: Ugh, yeah, I've learned by now that you always want at least that one snapshot in common to keep the continuity in the dataset.  Wouldn't I be able to recreate effectively the same thing by rsync'ing over each snapshot one by

Re: [zfs-discuss] combining series of snapshots

2010-06-08 Thread BJ Quinn
In my case, snapshot creation time and atime don't matter. I think rsync can preserve mtime and ctime, though. I'll have to double check that. I'd love to enable dedup. Trying to stay on stable releases of OpenSolaris for whatever that's worth, and I can't seem to find a link to download