>===== Original Message From John Daniele <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> =====
>Could you point me towards SOFTWARE (not STM equipment) that would be able
>to recover data that had been OVERWRITTEN from a sector of a drive?
>i.e. dd if=/dev/zero of=/dev/dsk/c0t0*
>Read each physical sector of the drive and explain to me how meaningful
>data is recovered from 00's using software recovery tools?
>John Daniele


I think all-inclusive statements, such as that by John in an earlier post, 
that a one-time pass will make data "unrecoverable" with standard forensic 
recovery methods is simply wrong. It's not a matter of which software could - 
or couldn't. It's a matter of what you mean by "standard" forensic recovery 
methods. You did not make clear what you meant by "standard" methods. If you 
mean Norton or McAfee Undelete when you speak of "forensic" methods - well 
then, we're talking different ball parks. Standard "forensic recovery methods" 
by big city US Police Departments and the FBI include more in their arsenal 
than simple data recovery programs. I am sure (or assume) the true is in 
Canada as well. The USA Dept. Of Defense (as you know) has protocols that are 
acceptable --- a three-pass method, a seven-pass method, and then there's the 
Gutmann method, which is acceptable to anybody, except maybe the Marines - who 
must blow their old drives to bits! (Pardon the pun).....But a one-time pass? 
Not acceptable for true security. And what good does it do to call something 
"unrecoverable" and NOT take into account slack space? Again, it comes back to 
the term "standard" -- I think the definition may be different in Canada than 
the United States.
- Mike Donovan  

Reply via email to