Sedalia Circuit Winkel 
Forensic Catholicization 
Grace, mercy, and peace to you from God our Father and from our Lord Jesus 
Christ! Amen. You might have heard these Words before: 
Jesus came and said to them, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been 
given to me. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in 
the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to 
observe all that I have commanded you.” 
Dear Christian friends, 
A few months ago, while praying the rite of confirmation, the vicar innocently 
wrote today’s sermon for me. (Thank you, vicar.) The opening words of the 
confirmation rite remind the student, “you have been baptized and catechized.” 
With understandable first-time jitters, the vicar tripped and I wrote it down: 
“You have been baptized and catholicized,” the vicar said. 
It is a rare and blessed moment when a slip-of-the-tongue draws us closer to 
the truth. Yes, we catechize people, that is, we baptize and teach them, as our 
Lord commanded us to do. In so baptizing and teaching, we catholicize them, 
that is, we make them part of what the Small Catechism calls “the one true 
faith” and “the whole Christian church on earth.” Catholicity is forensic. 
To clarify the point, let’s briefly review our first lessons in theology. 
•       The older pastors learned from Francis Pieper: “Justification is a 
forensic act, nothing but the judicial verdict of innocence” (III, 9). 
“Justification is not a physical, but a forensic act” (II, 403); “Justification 
is always used in the New Testament in the declaratory, the forensic sense” 
(II, 525). 
•       St. Paul speaks of forensic sanctification, too, that holiness is 
likewise imputed and declared to us on account of Christ. Paul used aorist 
passives: “You were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name 
of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God” (1 Corinthians 6:11). 
•       Shall we not think likewise of the resurrection? The resurrection of 
the body is your future hope and joyous certainty. “Your dead will live; their 
bodies shall rise” (Isaiah 26:19). But the resurrection also has a forensic 
aspect, declared power, in which we now live. “Consider yourselves dead to sin 
and alive to God in Christ Jesus. … Present your bodies to God as those who 
have been brought from death to life” (Romans 6:11, 13). 
•       “You have been baptized and catholicized,” said the vicar. You have 
been baptized and the one true faith—in its entirety—has been forensically 
credited to your account. To borrow an image from Helmut Thielicke, at Baptism 
you were fitted with catholicity 
like a country boy, with breeches that are too big, into which he must still 
grow up … Meanwhile, they hang loosely around his body, and this ludicrous 
sight of course is not beautiful (A Little Exercise for Young Theologians, 10). 
Sugar will dissolve into a turd. Heat will penetrate the surface of cold steel. 
“Every Word that comes from the mouth of God” (Matthew 4:4) creates what it 
states. God’s forensic declarations produce miraculous results. 
•       God’s forensic justification carries the powerful effect of gripping 
the one thus justified. We call that effect, that heart-quickening grasp, 
FAITH. 
•       The miracle God produces through His forensic declaration of 
sanctification might be called LOVE—love for God, love for neighbor. 
•       The miraculous result of forensic resurrection might be the ability to 
get out of bed in the morning, knowing that “neither height nor depth nor 
anything else in all creation will be able to separate us from the love of God 
in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 8:39). 
•       What word might describe the result of God’s forensic catholicization, 
that is, His baptismal declaration that you are part of “the whole Christian 
church on earth” and now hold “the one true faith”? Perhaps CATECHESIS will do. 
Jesus came and said to them, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been 
given to me. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in 
the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to 
observe all that I have commanded you.” 
God has declared you completely, 100% sanctified or holy, even though you are 
still warehousing great unholiness in your eyes and mind and heart. You are 
less loveless toward your neighbor than you were before, but you still have a 
long way to go. God’s forensic sanctification guards you and protects you along 
the way. 
God has declared you completely, 100% justified or righteous, even though you 
still are clearly out-of-plumb when it comes to your actions and your speaking 
and your thinking. But the power of God’s Word has made it possible for you to 
think better than you used to think, to trust Jesus more to trust, to despair 
more of your abilities and leave all things to God’s direction. But while we 
all still live in the potholes, God’s forensic justification remains whole and 
pure and undefiled, covering unjust you and despicable me from head to toe. 
God’s forensic catholicization will provide you with similar gifts, both for 
your person and for your office. Personally, neither you nor I will ever sound 
the depths of the one true faith. God forbid that we become masters, either of 
His Scriptures or His faith! “Who has measured the Spirit of the Lord?” (Isaiah 
40:13) “Who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been His counselor?” 
(Romans 11:34). “What no eye has seen, nor ear heard, nor the heart off man 
imagined… these things God has revealed to us through His Spirit” (1 
Corinthians 2:9). 
Just as it is abhorrent to travel roads that God has forbidden, so it is 
impossible to travel roads God has not opened. What shall we do? We shall 
“think with sober judgment, each according to the measure of faith that God has 
assigned” (Romans 12:3). What shall we do? We shall hold the Scriptures firmly 
in hand, each of us placing the finger of his preaching firmly upon God’s page, 
declaring with the mouth (Psalm 51:5) only those things that God has delivered 
to the eye (Psalm 119:18). What shall we do? Just as we trust God’s forensic 
justification, even while we repeatedly make people wonder whether we are 
indeed righteous; just as we trust God’s forensic sanctification, even as we 
repentantly hope to show better love for God and for neighbor; so we trust also 
God’s forensic catholicization, even while we devote ourselves to faithfulness 
and catholicity. The vicar said it so well: “You have been baptized and 
catholicized.” 
    
So also have the people whom God has placed into your care. We collectively 
face serious challenges in “teaching them to observe all that Jesus has 
commanded.” It is never hard to find a empty seat in the Bible study class. 
Confirmation instruction seems continually to test the limits—both the limits 
of what the students can neglect and the limits of what the pastor can forbear. 
Even those who faithfully devote themselves to your faithful teaching will 
occasionally stun you with the heterodox observations they make (mostly because 
their daughter married a Baptist). The Scriptures are indeed given, in part, 
for “rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness” (2 Timothy 4:2), but 
if we are not careful with our responses, we might teach people that the risk 
is too great for them to ask questions or make observations. 
Take comfort in God’s forensic catholicity. Know that you do not need to fix 
every detail of every person’s thinking in your congregation. Allow the living 
Word of God to do its catholicizing work—just as it does its justifying and 
sanctifying work—simply by means of your faithful repetition. 
While my sister delivered her firstborn, my mother stood by to hold her hand. 
At the moment of the child’s birth, my sister asked, “Does he look like a Caleb 
or does he look like a Joshua?” Wisely, my mother refused to answer the 
question. 
You may continue to call today’s Gospel “the Great Commission,” if you wish. 
But do you really want someone else to name your child? A more legalistic name 
can hardly be given. Alternatively, you could give today’s Gospel a somewhat 
wordier, but much more consoling, moniker. Something like, “Jesus’ Promise to 
Continue Making Disciples through Your Baptizing and Teaching,” might fit 
better. Perhaps “Forensic Catholicization” will do. Just stick the boy into his 
breeches. God will cause the growth. 
_______________________________________________
Sermons mailing list
[email protected]
http://cat41.org/mailman/listinfo/sermons

Reply via email to