Hi Noel. Noel J. Bergman schrieb: > Stefano Bagnara wrote: > > I'm sorry that you didn't understand my point, and that you're getting beaten > up in response. Let me try to be more clear. I am also going to reply in > three parts: one for each topic. > > >> Noel J. Bergman wrote: >> >>>> Fix Version/s: Next Major (was: Trunk) >>>> >>> Please stop doing this and messing up the JIRA issues. >>> > > >> I kept updated JIRA for the last year and more following this schema. >> > > >> As we did with 2.3 and trunk we agreed that everything we could have >> written for 2.3 would have been applied first in trunk and then >> backported. This way there is no issue applied to 2.3 that will not be >> in trunk. >> > > >> We created Next-Minor and Next-Major in JIRA for this very purpose, if >> we don't use this way, what should we use them for? >> > > IMO: > > 1) Issues should be marked as fixed for the code in which it is fixed. > 2) Unresolved issues could be marked as fixed for code in which it is > intended to be fixed. The problem with doing this is that someone > might close it, and not realize that the fix does not exist in the > branch housing that version. > > Now, let's consider next-major. As far as I know, we agree that the code in > trunk will branch to be next-major. BUT, we also agree that there is code in > trunk that may not survive the pruning. For example, perhaps none of the > IMAP stuff survives to ship in next-major. We decide that in order to have a > release in some timeframe, everything else is stable enough, but not certain > other parts. Those issues would be resolved in trunk, but *not* resolved in > next-major. Do you understand now why I am making this point? > > --- Noel > > Well i now better understand your point.. But i not agree with you.. if we remove some fixes from next-major or realize that its not fixed we should just remember changing JIRA.. Anyway if its so a big problem for you i can life with it.
bye Norman --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
