Hello Wojtek, As expressed here [a], I overall share the diagnostic and analsis, and proposes to work on (1): Parallelize the shutdown process. IE cheat on the guice wiring to register Netty components, register them, and do this in parallel. Here we need to be mindful that it do not mess up with the order of the shutdown - which relies on listening the order of instanciation of Guice components.
[a] https://github.com/apache/james-project/pull/2373#issuecomment-2295396500 Graceful shutdown is important at least for IMAP as it prevents some inconsistencies on the distributed mailbox. IMAP operation can be lengthy and to that end 2 seconds is not that much. I'd rather keep the graceful shutdown as it is but make it less painful. Thoughts? -- Best regards, Benoit TELLIER General manager of Linagora VIETNAM. Product owner for Team-Mail product. Chairman of the Apache James project. Mail: btell...@linagora.com Tel: (0033) 6 77 26 04 58 (WhatsApp, Signal) On Aug 17, 2024 6:02 PM, from Wojtek Hi, (folloup to the PR comment: github.com/apache/james-project/pull/2373#issuecomment-2294855488) As I found out the hard way, James takes a lot of time to perform clear/complete shutdown (log at the end[1]). As mentioned in the comment I see two main culprits: 1) `org.apache.james.protocols.lib.netty.AbstractServerFactory#destroy` destroys each server in sequence - making it parallel by using parallel stream instead of for-loop in already cuts down shutdown from 18s to 8 2) `is org.apache.james.protocols.netty.AbstractAsyncServer#unbind` with calls to io.netty.util.concurrent.EventExecutorGroup#shutdownGracefully() - by default they use quiet period of 2 seconds which makes each `.destroy()` call wait for 2 seconds which bumps the shutdown time. Without that the shutdown is almost instant. I'm not sure that having this default couple of seconds in this case makes sense as we are already in shutdown mode and unless services are closed first and then the rest of the James waits for it being closed then this grace period could actually be detrimental IMHO. [1] Shutdown log ``` james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:42.855] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose Manage Sieve Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:44.887] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose Manage Sieve Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:44.892] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose SMTP Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:46.915] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose SMTP Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:46.915] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose SMTP Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:48.940] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose SMTP Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:48.941] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose SMTP Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:50.974] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose SMTP Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:50.974] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose SMTP Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:52.998] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose POP3 Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:55.033] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose POP3 Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:55.034] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose IMAP Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:57.072] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose IMAP Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:57.073] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose IMAP Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:59.100] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose IMAP Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:01:59.100] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose IMAP Service james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:02:01.133] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] o.a.j.p.l.n.AbstractConfigurableAsyncServer.destroy(): Dispose IMAP Service done james-1 | [2024-08-17 13:02:01.157] [INFO ] [ Thread-0] t.j.CONFIGURATION.lambda$main$0(): JAMES server STOPPPED in: 18.312s ``` -- Wojtek --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: server-dev-unsubscr...@james.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: server-dev-h...@james.apache.org
