On 08/29/2010 08:27 PM, David Velazquez wrote:
> I agree with you here. Asking a beginner if it's ok to unmount a device
> before proceeding is counter-intuitive to me. If I were just starting off
> with Linux common sense would probably dictate that a device should be
> mounted before anything can be done with it. I get that it needs to be
> unmounted from one application to be used by another (or at least I think
> that's what happens), but that's not necessarily common knowledge and
> certainly would not be for someone new to all of this.
>    

I also agree.  In case it's not obvious to some of you on this mailing 
list, Shotwell can only import photos from a camera when it's 
*unmounted*.  When it's mounted, by contrast, the camera's filesystem 
shows up in Nautilus but Shotwell cannot read it.  Yes, this is 
confusing to beginners (and probably not only to beginners).

> On Sun, Aug 29, 2010 at 5:55 PM, thibaut bethune
> <[email protected]>wrote:
>
>    
>> Hi,
>>
>>  From a beginner point of view, having Shotwell asking if the camera
>> has to be unmounted before importing sounds a bit weird..!
>>
>> Lots of applications (see gThumb with Martin Pitt's patch) want to
>> unmount cameras before proceeding but it's a mistake to me. Once
>> unmounting, it can't be accessible through Nautilus for instance.
>> Applications should not fight against the system so Nautilus and
>> Shotwell could be able to share the device.
>>
>> Maybe you could look at phraymd (Python application) which succeed in
>> importing photos without unmounting the camera, which seems to be the
>> only way to proceed. For what i know i think that spillz (phraymd
>> developper) makes use of GVfs for that. Once he pointed out the GVfs
>> FUSE hack explained here :
>> http://davidz25.blogspot.com/2008/10/getting-gvfs-and-fuse-right.html,
>> adding : "Of course, the GVfs API provides higher level access than
>> what FUSE gives, so I will ultimately use that in phraymd."
>>      

I agree it would be nice if Shotwell could import photos from a camera 
without unmounting, and thanks for pointing out that phraymd does that.  
I don't know if that would be technically easy, though.  I've created a 
ticket (http://trac.yorba.org/ticket/2498) to track that idea.

adam
_______________________________________________
Shotwell mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.yorba.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/shotwell

Reply via email to