Re: Operations Directorate Review of draft-ietf-sidr-keyroThanks, and your 
suggested changes do address al my comments/concerns/questions,

bert
  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Stephen Kent 
  To: Bert (IETF) Wijnen ; [email protected] ; [email protected] 
  Cc: Geoff Huston ; [email protected] ; [email protected] ; Romascanu, Dan (Dan) ; 
Ron Bonica ; [email protected] 
  Sent: Wednesday, June 01, 2011 7:53 PM
  Subject: Re: Operations Directorate Review of draft-ietf-sidr-keyroll-06


  Elwyn,



    Nits/editorial comments:
    s4, s4.1 and s4.2:
    The  term 're-issue' is used in this section regarding the new
    certificates that the CA creates, e.g. in s4.1: 
      When a CA, as part of the key rollover process, re-issues a CA
         certificate,
    The term 're-issues' might be slightly confusing. Its a new certificate
    but with lots of fields the same.  I would be inclined to go with
    'issues new' but its a quibble.


  There is not uniform terminology for describing this sort of process in the 
PKI world, but the term "reissue" (or re-issue) is reasonable.  (It is distinct 
from cert "renewal," which implies a new cert with the same key and all 
attributes remaining constant except for the validity interval and serial 
number. Cert "re-key" refers to issuing a new cert with a new key, new serial 
number, maybe a new validity interval, but the same Subject name and other 
attributes remaining constant.)  Also, we use the same terminology in several 
other SIDR docs, e.g., draft-ietf-sidr-repos-struct-07.txt, 
draft-ietf-sidr-ta-07,  draft-ietf-sidr-res-certs-18, and in an analogous 
context in draft-ietf-sidr-rpki-manifests-11.txt.


  Steve


  ---------------------


  Bert,


  Responses to your comments below:


    ...

    RFC5706 suggests but does not require a separate
    "operational considerations section".

    The draft-ietf-sidr-keyroll-06 discusses the operational considerations
    in the "Security Considerations" section. I can live with that and leave it
    to the OPS ADs if they rather see that split out in a separate section
    or not.


  Thanks.



    Substantive comments/questions:

    - last para on page 4

       During the transition of the "current" and "new" CA instances it is
       necessary for the "new" CA instance to re-issue all subordinate
       products of the "current" CA.  The procedure described here requires

       I wonder if the "requires" should be a "REQUIRES" (yep, I know that
       rfc2119 does not have that exact capitalized form of require, but I
       think that a MUST or REQUIRED is intended here, no?)?

  How about:


      During the transition of the "current" and "new" CA instances the "new"
      CA instance MUST re-issue all subordinate products of the "current" CA. 



    - page 6
          4.  The NEW CA enters a Staging Period.  This duration of the
              Staging Period is determined by the CA, but it SHOULD be no
              less than 24 hours.
       Does/would it make sense to also suggest/recommend a max period?
       Would 48 hours make sense?


  A recommended max period is probably a good idea, since relying parties are
  burdened by having to deal with two sets of signed objects. If my co-author 
does not object, I would revise the text as follows:


  4.        The NEW CA enters a Staging Period.  This duration of the
            Staging Period is determined by the CA, but it SHOULD be no
            less than 24 hours.  (It is RECOMMENDED that the staging period
            be no longer than 48 hours.) ...





    - given the first para in sect 1, I wonder if ID.ietf-sidr-arch should be
       a normative instead of a informative reference.


  OK, that's an easy change.


    Editorial/nits:

    - sect 1. 1st sentence
       This document describes an algorithm to by employed by a

       s/by/be/  (the first occurrence of "by")


  OK.

    - page 4, at top:
      CURRENT:
          The CURRENT CA is the active CA instance used to accept and
          process certificate issuance and revocation requests The starting

      s/requests/requests./


  OK.

    - page 5
       expand acronym CPS on its first use in this document.


       used in the CURRENT CA certificate.  The Certificate Practice
       Statement  (CPS) for the issuer of the NEW CA certificate will
       indicate the time frame within which a certificate request is
       expected to be processed.






    - same for AIA acronym on page 6.


        -  Generate a new key pair, and generate an associated EE
           certificate request with an Authority Information Access (AIA)
           value of the NEW CA's repository publication point. 



    - page 6:
      4.  The NEW CA enters a Staging Period.  This duration of the

      s/This duration of the/The duration of this/


  OK

    - page 8
       expand acronym CMS on its first use in this document.


       (If the signing time or binary signing time values in the Cryptograpic
       Message Syntax (CMS) wrapper are non-null, they MAY be updated to
       reflect the current time.)




  Steve
_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to