At 12:46 PM -0300 6/21/11, Arturo Servin wrote:
Stephen,

        Thanks for the reply, it clarifies my questions.

        Just one nit:
...

Would it be possible to say what to do to validate objects in 4.5? Perhaps:

"
   An RP that validates all signed product sets using both Algorithm
Suite A or Algorithm Suite B, SHOULD expect the same results. Objects are valid if they are signed using either Algorithm
   Suite A or Algorithm Suite B.
"


We could add text to 4.5 to make it clearer what an RP ought to do, but I fear that the text above might confuse an RP.

When I read it I get the sense that different answers from the two alg suites indicates a problem. What we want to say is that an RP can use validated results from either set of signed objects. So, if you fetch both sets, and validate one set first, then you are done. if you try to validate one set and fail, then try the other. if that one validates, you are OK. Only of both sets cannot be validate is there a problem.

Steve
_______________________________________________
sidr mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr

Reply via email to