On Thu, Sep 8, 2016 at 9:32 AM, Heasley <[email protected]> wrote: > > > Am 08.09.2016 um 00:42 schrieb Randy Bush <[email protected]>: > > >> Or maybe there's pushback that says: "Hey, I hear what you all in the > >> rir want, but it's not cool, please please let's dive back into the > >> politics stream and see how we get movement on what we all (probably?) > >> want: a single root for this system." > > Or can the RIRs be removed from the equation? Why must we care what the > RiRs want (fitting of many questions surrounding the RIRs)? Theyre > essentially just agents of the IANA, its not inconceivable to replace them > or separate duties. > > sure... I think sriram may cover this in his document about the decision processes which lead to where we are today.
I think, one way to look at the document and situation is this: o community folks for each RIR asked for RPKI to be supported o RIR folk put in some development $$/effort to do that o no single-root came forward o to make the RPKI work, specifically for xfers, or one way wrt transfers, is to fake the root at each RIR. o rpki progress can still be made until single-root arrives, and then some re-signing and probably rough work would have to happen to move under the single-root. sure lots of evil other things could be afoot, but I don't see evidence of that. again, perhaps it's worth the community folks (outside the ietf) just saying: "I hear what you're saying, I like your want to keep this going forward, but REALLY we need to sort out the issues around 'single-root' and get that done.. the operational cost to not having a 'single-root' is just too damned high." <https://imgflip.com/i/1a8y83> > > > > the iab did that and got a written agreement that the rirs would do so. > > nothing more is needed other than action. apologies for not being up on the chain-of-command, but this doesn't seem like it's enough... we've been waiting, what are the blockers? why can't this action move forward? (yes, politics, let's move that to anyother list I suppose) -chris
_______________________________________________ sidr mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sidr
