Yup -- I wrote about IMS in my VON column. IMS in 2006 but have learned a lot 
more since about how bad an idea it was.

This is why I wrote https://rmf.vc/IEEEERefactoringCE other writings because 
the Internet makes absolutely no sense to at traditional telco framing. I often 
tell the story about kid in class next to me who put implemented ALOHAnet using 
a coaxial cable as an ether (yes, Bob Metcalfe). He advisors wanted him to 
prove it was efficient and met his promised 2.994 MHz capacity. But what does 
the mean, At the time 9600 was a fast connection so what if it was used 1% of 
the potential 3Mbps capacity? That still an amazing improvement.

They were only able to look at it from the perspective of a service delivery 
system. They were unable to see that it was just a chunk of copper that was 
intrinsically unable to implement the smarts they wanted. The big surprise was 
that taking out all the smarts, the second-guessing, was liberating. That might 
not be obvious because many people assume that in the absence of a central 
authority we'd get chaos. THis is why the Internet is a wonderful laboratory in 
how systems can emerge not despite the lack of control but because of it. And a 
test to see if people can accept world that is not strictly hierarchical. 
Identity is simple "=" and authentication and trust are intrinsically ambiguous 
but those who see the world as hierarchical have difficulty with that.

This site (IMS) is a case study in an attempt to turn the clock by the same 
people who gave us SNA and SS7 in the 1970s. You're devices are added value on 
their network. The telling comment in that was the statement that IMS was 
necessary for VoLTE (Voice of LTE) even after VoIP had proved that the lack of 
the control plane was the enabler.

The key is to understand that the success of the Internet has 0% to do with 
bits per second and everything to do with factoring the infrastructure from 
what we do with it

This diagram is classic telecom with all the services inside the [broadband] 
pipe which functioned as a delivery system

[byte limits prevents image so imagine a pipe with services

====== Broadband Pipe =================
[phone calls] [home shopping] [Internet] [tv] [Netflix]
===================================

This is the new reality: with the services entirely outside the pipe.

.................................................

[phone calls] [home shopping] [Internet] [tv] [Netflix]

====== Leaky Broadband Pipe ==============
              Just meaningless packets -- no op
===================================

.............................................

In the classic model neutrality is asking the owner of the pipe to forego 
monetization and using the pipe to their advantage. That's like telling the fox 
not to eat the chickens it is guarding. In the new model there isn't the 
opportunity to be non-neutral

ALso, to response to Christopher A Kantarjiev via Silklist 
<[email protected]> wrote:

Yes, roads and sidewalks are the right analogy. We pay for them in a way to 
make them free to uses . They are user-facing infrastructure in the sense use 
them directly unlike water pipes or the old telecom model in which we only see 
the water and only telecom services. The idea of phone companies becoming banks 
is interesting. AT&T but gave up. M-Pesa is more interesting in treating 
telephone minutes as a currency. What happens now that billing for minutes is 
increasingly a relic of the past? 



On 8/11/2026, 1:07:26 PM, Vijay Anand <[email protected]> wrote:

“How about you become a DESTINATION instead of a fat pipe?”

This reminds me of the frenzy around IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem) around 2011. 
In a sense, some of what was proposed had merit. One idea was a more 
authenticated, policy-aware internet, where identity, authorization and policy 
could make things like age-based access to social media or adult content much 
easier to implement.

It was another attempt to move some intelligence and value back into the 
network. Just that the genie wasn’t going back into the bottle. By the time 
“Net Neutrality” gained momentum, the idea of letting the network become a 
policy and service layer had become politically toxic.
-- 
Silklist mailing list
[email protected]
https://mailman.panix.com/listinfo.cgi/silklist

Reply via email to