On 2/5/06, Ashish Gulhati <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> "It is a sin to write this."  (Anthem)
>
> "Howard Roark laughed." (The Fountainhead)
>
> "Petrograd smelt of carbolic acid." (We The Living)
>
> and possibly the most well-known first line from a novel
> ever:
>
> "Who is John Galt?" (Atlas Shrugged)

Can someone explain to me why a First Sentence that cannot hold its
own without its surrounding context deserve fame separate from the
larger work?  As a case in point, the four lines quoted above, and
many others in that larger list.  What do you see in them?  I see
nothing special.

-Karra

P.S.: I suspect that by the standards of Silk, I would border on being
literarily challenged.  So... :-)

Reply via email to