On Tuesday 11 Dec 2007 3:25 pm, Abhijit Menon-Sen wrote: > It's not ad hominem. If he'd said "you're a right-wing Hindu murderer, > so the results of your study are wrong", it would have been ad hominem. > But he's saying you have no data to substantiate your argument. That he > says you're cheap may be a nasty dig, but it's not ad hominem.
Everyone is entitled to his view. You have yours. I have mine. > That "makes you" a murderer of Christians only insofar as it allows you > to exaggerate what you perceive as a bias against anyone who identifies > themselves as Hindu. Or do you think Thaths really can't or doesn't see > any distinction between you and the people who burned Graham Staines? Cut the boring rhetoric boss. I have no idea what Thaths thinks. But I can see that Thaths is a decent guy. shiv
