----- Original Message -----
From: Fred <[email protected]>

> Ivan said:
> So yesterday I hit the books etc. and found that the conductivity of
> dilute solutions of silver ions is 61.9 Scm^2 M^-1 that is Semen
> centimetre squared per Mol.
> This is probably where Hanna derived their 1.6 conversion factor,
but
> this refers to Mols of silver not ppm.
> When converted to mg/L we find that: 1mg/L (1ppm) Ag+ = .574 uS/cm
or
> 1uS = 1.74ppm
> --------------------------------------------------------------
> I am at a loss, as I can not recall the definition of a MOL - gram
molecular???

1mole = 6.02 x 10^23 atoms (or molecules, Avogadro's number) and is
equal to the atomic weight expressed as grams. In the case of silver
1mole = 107.87 grams.

> I respect your theory but find it hard to believe Hanna has been
selling mis-
> calibrated instruments for 20 years without their peers slamming
them! Do
> you have a web source for the "61.9 Scm^2 M^-1 that is Semen
centimetre
> squared per Mol".

http://www.compusmart.ab.ca/plambeck//che/p415/p15062.htm

(think you ment uS/cm and Siemen? or are we talking
> 61,900 micro-Seimen - again forgot what a mol is)

(I wonder if there is a relationship between Avogadro's number and
Semen)

Hanna's instruments are not mis-calibrated, they read the conductivity
of the solution, and their standard solutions are certified correct
(NIST traceable), but the conversion factors for the small TDS meters
are only *near enough* and follow the industry standard.
Take the conversion factor of 0.5 (or 2) for CaCO3 for example, the
conversion factor is never reached in real solutions, see:
http://www.omega.com/techref/ph-2.html CaCO3 is a special case (2 x
bivalent atoms) and does not follow the conductivity rules of
univalent atoms (I should never have included it), but because it is a
common dissolved solid and its molecular weight of 100.09, it is easy
to use in the *equivalent weight method* ie molecular weight divided
by the valency per uS.

As for silver, I think that Hanna have simply said decided that its
molecular weight (107.87) is close enough to 100 that the ppm ratio is
directly related to the molarity of an aqueous solution 100 to 1.
Which gives (ignoring how the units were derived) 0.619 uS per ppm.
Taking the inverse we find 1.62ppm per uS.
However, if we use the actual mw of silver we have a ratio of 108 to 1
then 0.619 x 100 / 108 = 0.573 uS / ppm... or 1.74 ppm / uS.

I derived this result for a number of compounds using the individual
limiting ionic conductances, notably Na+, K+ and Cl- and was able to
check my results with published results for NaCl and KCl with good
correlation, especially after factoring in the change in conductance
in relation to the concentration as described by Kohlrausch's Law and
as developed in the Debye - Huckel - Onsager theory. A discussion on
the conductivity of ions can be found in Physical Chemistry - Atkins
which most libraries should have, one can read the theory without
needing to understand the maths.

> This is rather distressing, to become so unsure of who to respect,
do you
> or anyone else have a web based scientific encyclopedia source? The
poor
> folks who do not enjoy trying to understand the techi stuff must
really be
> lost!

I should think that quite a few silvertails will be interested in the
outcome of these discussions, if only in that the conclusion may be
that a cheap conductivity meter can provide reliable concentration
information for silver colloids or sols fitting certain parameters.

I only include the method and maths so that others who are competant
can verify or refute my conclusions, or for those who are just plain
interested. The rest may simply ignore these messages.

> [email protected]

heads up - Ivan.



--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]

List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>