Hi James Allison,

I am not qualified to authoritatively make pronouncements about these 
things.  I think that is reserved for a physical chemist who is a 
specialist.  I have not yet found an accessible one.

There are a few items about which I feel confidant.

I meant to say what I said, at least in the instance to which you refer.

My working definition of CS is a small clump of silver with a + I [or 
greater] charge.

By definition, any charged particle is an ion, be it a single atom of a 
single element, a molecule of the same material, or a compound.

A monatomic atom, with its valence presenting is what I call "ionic" 
silver. Some colloidal silver is charged, and meets the definition of being 
"ionic".  No dissolved silver meets the criteria to be called a colloid. It 
is silver "in aqueous solution".

The vague term "static charge" is used by some to discriminate between the 
dissolved single-atom "silver ion", and a charged colloid.

Colloids, if charged, are ions. [Perhaps there is an upper limit to this 
definition in terms of size.  Certainly anything small enough to be kept 
afloat by Brownian movement will be so classified]

 At issue: is the charge originating from a missing electron in the outer 
ring of a single atom of the silver in the crystal, or is it being created 
through the interaction of the particle with surrounding water, and/or 
surrounding disassociated water ions?  Or something else. I have even 
suspected there is a proton in there somewhere.  Lacking evidence to the 
contrary, I maintain that speculation.

A single atom of silver in water is dissolved ionic silver.  It is not a 
colloid.

Dissolved silver is much more chemically reactive than a cluster of silver 
atoms, regardless of the presence or lack of charge on the cluster. It is 
much more likely to react with other ions and create undesirable compounds. 

My definition of an Ag sol is a silver particle of more than one atom.  It 
may or may not have a charge.  If it has no charge, it is still a colloid. 
 If charged, it is still a colloid.  A single atom of silver in water will 
be charged, and is not by any definition a colloid.

I don't think this charge originates from a single atom on the cluster 
loosing one 'tron. When you find someone who knows, I would appreciate 
having access to the information.

The HVAC Ag sol I make contains virtually no monatomic dissolved silver. 
And, the pH of the water  in = the pH out of the generator, within the 
limits of my clunky instrumentation in that area.

My process produces no sludge and no plating, except perhaps some on the 
electrodes themselves.

The photos which Steve Quinto publishes tell nothing about the crystal 
angles; they only show the relatively gross outline of the particles.  He, 
in spite of his plethora of quais-technical verbiage doesn't have a clue 
either, at least about the details herein discussed.

X-ray diffraction is needed to visualize the crystal structure.  Electrons 
do not have the resolution.  How do you image an electron with an electron?

Can you define "distorted crystal of silver".  What are the bonding angles 
in distorted v. undistorted?

And please note: I have nothing to support or prove or defend.  I just want 
to know how it works.

James Osbourne Holmes
[email protected]
FTNWO


-----Original Message-----
From:   Fred [SMTP:[email protected]]
Sent:   Friday, June 16, 2000 11:02 AM
To:     [email protected]
Subject:        CS>Re: Your Last Comments on my HVAC CS were lost


>Hi Fred,
>
>"Dark sludge" is not "tiny" particles of elemental silver, and usually
>contain compounds.  I am speaking of particles of 0.999+ fine silver in 
the
>0.5 to 10 nm range with a high Zeta charge.  These, by definition, are
>ions, but are by definition, not dissolved.    They are "tiny particles of
>elemental silver".
>
>James Osbourne Holmes
>[email protected]

You seem to have gone full circle there James! I believe you ment to
say "by definition they are colloids" not "they are ions"! It is my
understanding that an ion is an atom of silver less an electron and
thus no longer can be called elemental silver!

I was referring to the reduced silver ions on the negative electrode 
(sludge)
which are atoms and grow as soft crystal structures. In a better medium
(silver plating uses cyanuric acid to promote fine crystal structure) you 
would
see a hard mirror like silver coating.The "sludge" occurs there and in the 
dark
stingers, with no contaminates present! It is elemental silver!

I am sure the HVAC process also produces some ions, but I suspect from
the discussions of "sputtering metal from a super heated point" that the
bulk of the product is elemental silver that was quickly quenched and forms
distorted crystals of silver, as well documented by one of the list 
members,
including his photos (sorry, I lost his site address, but you may have
saved it).

[email protected]


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to:
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>