Barrett/Renner “Anti-Health Campaign” fizzles in Minnesota.

Minnesota recently passed, and signed into law, one of the most
comprehensive health reform bills in the history of the United States.
The bill passes both houses of the State legislature with a huge majority,
and was signed by the Governor despite a massive lobbying effort by what
health leaders call "the minions of the drug barons."

Apparently, the people of the State of Minnesota woke up one morning and
decided that they wanted “real health care” in their State.  So they put a
group together, wrote a definitive health bill,  hand-carried it through the
legislature, and up to the Governor’s desk, and said "Hey Jesse, sign
here..."  Jesse did.

They wanted their health bill to protect their right to freedom of choice,
and to keep their practitioners free from harassment - while establishing
guidelines.  GOOD idea.

They did it.  It’s done.  The Governor signed the bill Thursday, May 11th,
2000.  And now, Minnesota leads the nation with the best, most comprehensive
health bill in the country.  It is a law to copy, everywhere.

And, despite opposition from the "drug lord minions," they did it easily.

I’d say “Congratulations” to them, if they’d accept it - and maybe they
will.  But I have the feeling that Minnesota would shrug, and say something
like “we just did what we needed to do - what’s the big deal?”

The fact is, it is a big deal - because Minnesota did it first, and they did
it best.

So, whether you want to hear it, or not, Minnesota, “Congratulations.”

Oh, and by the way, “THANK YOU VERY MUCH.”

THE “QUACKPOT MENACE (Barrett, Renner, et al)”  was there, of course, trying
to stop “The People’s” efforts. But their performance was, well, in kind
words, “laughable.”

Apparently Barrett and Renner, in the beginning, were confident that their
local team in Minnesota could deal with the problem.  “After all,” they must
have said, “we have our very own legislator (‘Doc Mulder’) on tap.”  “And,”
they must have said, “we have our very own ‘quack museum - the Museum of
Questionable Medical Devices’ - right there in Minneapolis. That should do
it...”

But, it didn’t...

Despite the best efforts of Barrett’s Minnesota henchmen, who, to the
apparent amusement of elected officials,  screeched up and down the halls of
the legislature screaming “this is a witchcraft bill,” the bill passed the
House with a vote of 111 to 23.  Stunned, I’d guess, Barrett’s local lead
man muttered all the way back to his “museum.”

For the quackpots then, it was time to bring in the “Big Guns” and “show
these Minnesotans Who’s Who.”  So, on the scene pops Stephan Barrett (don’t
call him doctor) himself  - interviewed (yawn) on Minnesota Public Radio.
And then, entering from stage left is “the man, himself,” the President of
the National Council For Reliable Health Information - John Renner - who,
apparently,  tells Minnesota legislators that “A multi-million dollar New
York law firm is responsible for the Minnesota Health Freedom bill.”

I heard the legislators' laughter could be heard in South Dakota...

Did the mighty Renner and Barrett, the scions of so-called anti-quackery,
have an effect on the bill’s future?  Oh yeah!   The Senate passed the
health bill 80 to 1.

Then, of course, the Governor signed it.

WHAT’S NEXT?

Well, I suggest, in every State, it’s time to go to the next logical step...

For instance, isn’t it time for a “Physician’s Re-Training Act” - a bill
designed to force MD s to upgrade their skills - or lose their licenses?
MDs just don’t keep up with the needs of the public - they seem to want to
just peddle dangerous drugs, or push costly, and unnecessary, “surgeries.”

And then, a “Physician’s Review Act,” where a citizen’s committee can review
an MDs practice to determine whether he/she is using expensive, and
personally profitable, drug “treatments” where he/she should be using
natural “cures,” or dealing with the “cause” of an illness.  This bill could
provide for license removal and the seizure of assets of convicted
offenders - the assets could be put into a fund for MD “victims.”

Then, a “Medical Board Revision Act,” designed to remove all MDs from state
medical boards, and replace them with citizens (like they are doing in
Ontario, Canada - right now).  Give them a mandate to clean up the MD’s
act - with police, assett seizure, and arrest, powers.  MDs, as a group,
have shown an inability to regulate themselves - and are abusing their
regulatory power to stifle, and destroy, competition for health dollars.

Then a “Hospital Reform Act...”  And then, and then,,,

Here's the story from the Minnesota Health Reform team, in their own
words...

-------------------------------------------------------------

Minnesota Natural Health Legal Reform Project
3236 17th Ave. S, #1
Minneapolis, MN 55407
(612) 721-3305

Health News    June 6, 2000

Minnesota Governor Jesse Ventura signs ”Health Care Freedom of Access Bill.”


The “Complementary and Alternative Health Care Freedom of Access bill” in
Minnesota was designed to protect freedom of access to health care in
Minnesota.  The Legislature, and the Governor, took on, and solved, a
difficult problem facing Americans.

This successful reform caps a grassroots campaign, waged in Minnesota,  over
several years, to better assure consumer access to the kind of health care
desired by Americans.

CONSUMER FREEDOM OF ACCESS:  The bill has been hailed as a national
bellweather signaling a long overdue recognition of freedom to practice for
alternative health care practitioners. A consumer's freedom of access is
dependent on the practitioner's freedom to practice, of course, much as the
public's freedom of access to information  rests on the writer's freedom to
write freely and without suppression by state laws or actions.

The health freedom movement in Minnesota was galvanized in the mid-90s by
high profile legal actions taken against the state's most prominent
alternative health care practitioners, both licensed and unlicensed.  One
case involved St. Paul naturopathic doctor Helen Healy, who was charged with
the  "practice of medicine" without a license.  Despite the absence of
consumer complaints and any allegations of patient harm, the state's Medical
Board sought to shut down Healy's practice immediately and permanently. The
public outcry helped save Healy from being shut down; she settled out of
court before her trial. But it also helped spur a new thirst for greater
protection of consumer freedom of access and a desire to affirm the
practitioner's right to practice with fairer treatment under the law.

A citizen 'legal committee" that researched the legal obstacles to health
freedom eventually became the nonprofit Minnesota Natural Health Legal
Reform Project, which spearheaded the legal reform effort.

THE CRUX OF THE PROBLEM for all unlicensed practitioners, including Helen
Healy, is  the overly broad definition, in most States, of the term
"practice of medicine."  The sweeping definition includes anyone who
undertakes to diagnose, correct, treat or even prevent any disease, illness,
pain or infirmity by any manner or means; such people  are practicing
medicine, according to existing law, and must be licensed medical doctors.

Nurses, dentists, chiropractors and other licensed health professionals
escape charges of practicing medicine without a license because they have an
exemption to the overly broad statute. But there is no such protection for
the unlicensed alternative health care practitioner; they can be charged
with practice of medicine whenever a complaint gets the medical board's
attention.

The fallout of this legal vulnerability is far-ranging: it includes a fear
of becoming too prominent, a fear of being too commercially successful, a
fear of being the innovator and a fear of being seen as outspoken in
criticizing the more commonly used methods of treatment.

As a result of the fear and intimidation, consumers can tend to be deprived
of the benefits of the most honest discussions that they could have with
their practitioners, and of the most innovative treatment methods.

The practitioners themselves may be forced into early retirement, or they
and
their treatment option, could be difficult to find.

LICENSURE AND TURF BATTLES:  If the state of Minnesota deems it desirable to
regulate an occupation, it is state policy to only regulate the occupation
with the least restrictive manner and only when an occupation would pose an
imminent risk of harm to the public.  In view of that, legislative health
committees have declined to allow licensure for currently unlicensed
modalities such as  naturopathy to go forward. A registration bill for
massage therapists has also been tabled.

Licensure and registration approaches have other drawbacks; they  seem to
set up battle lines among practitioners,  between those that would be
allowed to practice under the proposed licensure and those that would be
excluded. Minnesota's new approach to affirming health freedom avoids
stirring up those kind of turf battles.

MINNESOTA’S HEALTH FREEDOM SOLUTION:  To assure consumer access to as
many practitioners as possible, the state of Minnesota has set up a new
office to provide government oversight to unlicensed practitioners. In turn,
the practitioners practicing under the new statute will be exempt from
criminal charges of practice of medicine without a license. The office will
oversee those who are practicing "the broad domain of complementary and
alternative healing methods and treatments."  Naturopathy, homeopathy and
herbalism are just a few of the therapies listed in the statute as examples
of practices that the new chapter of law deals with.  A set of 24 rules of
ethical conduct is given for the new office to oversee. The office will
receive consumer complaints, investigate them, and enforce the ethical
rules. The ethical rules include prohibitions against fraud, false or
misleading advertising, sexual contact with a client, and inability to
practice  "with reasonable safety … to the client." The rules of conduct are
clearly not intended  to allow suppression of  therapies on the grounds that
they are new or different from conventional practice.  "The fact that a
…practice may be a less customary approach to health care shall not
constitute the basis of a disciplinary action per se," the new law states.

The new law takes effect July 1, 2000.

HOW THEY DID IT:   A statewide grassroots lobbying effort by the
reform project helped move the health freedom bill through the tougher
committee battles. A core of about eight leaders meet one night a week for
three years to drive the effort forward.

Serving as the reform project's legal consultant was Diane Miller who,
supported by a volunteer legal team, formulated the freedom approach behind
the bill.  Miller along with citizen-turned-lobbyist Jerri Johnson, a local
homeopath,  led the lobbying work at the capitol. and helped to navigate the
bill through 15 committees.
Consumers in all parts of the state - outstate as well as metro - played a
role in reaching their elected officials. They gathered with their
legislators in their districts to share their stories of the personal
importance of alternative care options and to demand active reform. After a
while, it was obvious that, for the people of Minnesota, this reform bill
had very broad support.

THE CHIEF AUTHOR IN THE HOUSE was state Representative Lynda Boudreau, a
republican. Her leadership in moving the bill through key house
policy committees was crucial. With the help of supportive colleagues,
Boudreau was able to move the bill through intense amendment discussions,
meet the committees' concerns and produce a bill that would meet broad
support.

THEN IT WAS LARGELY THE SENATE’S TURN, with the committee deadline clock
ticking. State Senator Twyla Ring, a new democratic senator, dramatically
piloted the bill through three hearings in one week.  Senator Ring had
agreed to take up the senate authorship after the death of a previous senate
author, Senator Janet Johnson, last August.  Elected in a special election
to fill the vacancy left by Johnson's death, Sen. Ring, had been a personal
friend of Johnson's.  Sen. Ring became strongly committed to helping finish
the senate journey for health freedom that her friend Janet had begun. With
the help of many of her senate colleagues.
she did just that.

After going through a conference committee, final passage in both
houses was by strong  margins. On May 1st, the House approved the bill by
110 to 23, following a final, lively debate. The final senate approval for
the bill on May 4th was by a 58 to 1. The freedom train had arrived.

Governor Ventura's policy advisors supported the health freedom bill and the
governor's office was deluged with calls from citizens urging that he sign
the bill.  Without fanfare, Ventura signed the bill May 11th.

Although the governor doesn't grant photo opportunities when signing bills,
he is meeting later this month to meet and do photos with some of the
citizens who were behind the landmark health freedom reform in Minnesota.

CONTACTS:

Leo Cashman,  organizer                            612 721-3305
Diane Miller,   legal consultant & lobbyist    c/o 612 721-3305
Nancy Hone , local homeopath                       651 647-9908
Jerri Johnson,  homeopath, lobbyist                651 688-6515
Rep. Lynda Boudreau, chief house author            651 296-8237
Sen. Twyla Ring, chief senate author               651 296-5419
Marillyn Beyer, health educator                    612 926-5456



--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>