Terry Wayne, thank you.  I am sure that is exactly what I did wrong.  Used 
one 9V battery, with rather short wires, that would have put the distance at 
about a max of 2 inches, on the fingers.  
Haven't tried it yet with the electrode on each side, but will try this first 
with the smaller 9v and then 2 9v, and then work up (electrode on each side) 
.  This should make a difference.  Thank you.

Suzy,
I am constructing a device for a friend. I bought a DC
adapter which has a switch that gives a range of
voltages: 1.5v, 3v, 4.5v, 6v, 7.5v, 9v, and 12v. Using
this gizmo, a person could start off at the bottom and
work up until comfort became a factor. In your case, I
would not position the electrodes too close to each
other. I personally place the electrodes (2 TENS unit
electrode pads, but you could use the sponge idea) on
each side of my abdomen. When I place them much
closer, it becomes uncomfortable in a minute or two.
(But this is with 12-volts. I haven't tried it with
lower voltages.)  Have you tried it with an electrode
on each side?
Terry Wayne