Joe said--

> I appreciate the information about vapors and absorption.
> I'll so some research in the archives etc. when time permits.
> If I do check the archives, will I find the answer to my question
> about the actual amounts released as vapor, etc.?

Good and critical question.  There seems to be a lack of good quantitative
information anywhere to help those trying to dissuade sick people  from
going through unnecessary dental surgery.  We should be able to state quite
categorically what levels of mercury exposure have been shown to cause
illness, in what is surely by now a considerable experience of accidental
and occupational exposure, and compare them to the exposure possible through
dental fillings.

All I have been able to find in relation to the latter are the following two
studies referring to urinary mercury levels, which presumably will be
related to total exposure in any steady state.

They seem to show that you would need about 30 amalgam surfaces to produce
the urinary mercury levels warranting further monitoring of mercury workers
using the strictest industrial standards applied by some countries.
Regardless, tbese still seem to be several orders of magnitude below the
levels that have  ever been associated with detectable damage, even when
looking for subclinical nerve conduction or tremor effects.

I have also never found a study showing a correlation between the presence
of amalgams with any illness, even from anti-amalgamists, and there are a
number of negative ones.

Two studies ----.

1. [Dental amalgams and urine elimination of mercury in workers exposed to
low concentrations of inorganic mercury].

[Article in Italian]

Soleo L, Pesola G, Vimercati L, Elia G, Michelazzi M, Gagliardi T, Drago I,
Lasorsa G.

Dipartimento di Medicina Interna e del Lavoro, Universita di Bari.

The aim of the research was to assess the contribution of dental amalgams
and other non-occupational factors of exposure to inorganic mercury (diet,
etc.) to the quantity of mercury excreted with urine in workers exposed to
low level concentrations of inorganic mercury. Two groups of workers (Groups
I and II) were studied who were exposed to low and different environmental
concentrations of inorganic mercury. These two groups were compared with a
group of subjects not occupationally exposed to mercury in the same
geographical area (Group III). All subjects were administered a
questionnaire concerning personal data, lifestyle, recent removal and/or
insertion of dental amalgam fillings, presence of nasal obstruction or
bruxism and consumption of fish. The number of amalgam-filled teeth was
established for each subject. Mean environmental exposure to inorganic
mercury was 0.0087 mg/m3 for Group I and 0.0030 mg/m3 for Group II. Urinary
excretion in the 3 groups was 4.2 +/- 2.8 micrograms/l for Group I, 3.0 +/-
2.1 micrograms/l for Group II and 1.6 +/- 1.2 micrograms/l for Group III.
The results showed that of the factors of exposure to inorganic mercury,
only occupational exposure (T = 9.18; p = 0.000) and the number of
amalgam-filled teeth (T = 2.03; p = 0.043) were able to influence
significantly urinary excretion of mercury; the sources of non-occupational
exposure did not appear to play any role. The contribution of each amalgam
filling to urinary mercury excretion was calculated to be 0.08 microgram/l.
Occupational exposure therefore, even at low level doses, is still the main
cause of urinary mercury excretion in workers exposed to inorganic mercury;
of the non-occupational exposure factors, a significant role is played by
amalgam dental fillings, whose contribution needs to be taken into
consideration in order to make a correct interpretation of the results of
biological monitoring of exposed workers.

PMID: 9734193 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

2. And a similar figure (over ten fillings) from a study done on American
soldiers, given to me by an anti-amalgam crazy.  I don't have the reference
to hand, sorry, but pubmed may have it-----


For this large military population that had a range of from 0
to
>66 amalgam filling surfaces and an average of 20 surfaces, each 10 surfaces
>added approximately 1 microgram of mercury per liter of urine excreted,
meaning
>total mercury excreted in urine averaged about 4.5 micrograms per day, with
>soldiers levels with over 49 amalgam surfaces averaging over 8.7
micrograms.
>The average level for those with fillings was 4.5 times that of the
controls
>without amalgam, and those with over 49 surfaces averaged over 8 times
>controls. Together with the considerably larger amount of mercury excreted
>daily through the digestive tract and sweat, the daily mercury excretion
would
>amount to well over 10 micrograms per day on average and much more for some
>individuals.   Over 90 % of the mercury in the urine was inorganic mercury,
the
>kind that comes from fillings, as opposed to organic mercury which comes
from
>fish.>

Peter Moran