Reid, Please understand I've been dealing with this company for several years and have actually spoken to their lab technicians who beyond assured me they only are using silver and distilled water. After Frank's analysis, this is obviously not the case. I personally don't want to take a MSP and I have been mislead. I never claimed this product was a 'bad thing'-I've been taking it for several years. Simply-their labeling is a bad thing.
Maryanne ----- Original Message ----- From: "Reid Harvey" <[email protected]> To: "silver list" <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, August 15, 2003 10:50 PM Subject: Re: CS>Innovative Natural Products Analysis > Dear Frank and Bob, > I too would like to thank you for checking out the Innovative products. > I think the list has already covered a lot of ground in discussion of > ingesting dilute, concentrated CS, but I'm not sure I agree with > Pow-Map's suggestion this product would be such a bad thing. While I > take Ole Bob's point that ingesting silver compounds is not a good idea, > past conversation has suggested the amount of silver protein stabilizer > may be as low as 1.0% or so. > > What this suggests to me is that while diluting the CS to about 10 ppm > the amount of compound gets down to about 0.1 ppm. I'm imagining that > there would be lots of circumstances where use of this product in this > way would be beneficial, the deleterious effects rather limited. For > example, CS enthusiasts, while traveling, may find it difficult to take > along liters of CS or their generators. So this product may be > appropriate. > > Please bear in mind that I'm posing all of this as a question to the > knowledgeable, though my approach may be rhetorical. On the other hand > recent observations indicate Mexican Microdyn may contain somewhat more > than 1.0% silver compound. Others on the list have observed that the > poor in Mexico may be enjoying much better health than their > counterparts to the north, and I've heard nothing about turning gray or > blue, south of the border. But then I'd imagine that poor Mexicans have > a lot more to worry about than cosmetic effects. > > Please forgive the temptation to commentary. > Reid > > Pow-Map wrote: > Dear Frank and Bob, > > I want to thank you both for testing the Innovative products I sent to > you. > This boggles my mind that they're mislabeling their products and I plan > to > do something about it. > Frank, I want to sincerely thank you for testing this product for me, > and > for all the people on this list to see. It was so very kind of you (and > > informative). > > Thanks to all, > Maryanne > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Robert Berger" <[email protected]> > To: <[email protected]> > Sent: Wednesday, August 13, 2003 9:38 PM > Subject: Re: CS>Innovative Natural Products Analysis > > > > Hi EIS'ers, > > > > Like Frank I received a sample of Innovative Natral Prodycts 1100 ppm > "colloidal > > silver." > > > > One characterisitic of high ppm silver compounds is that it has an > orange > color > > to it that will stain papr or cloth. When a CS or EIS product has > color it > will > > not stain as the color that one sees is due to the particles adsorbing > > part of > > the white light spectrum. > > > > This material check out at 1700+ ppm using my spectrophotometer. > > > > My personal opinion would be to avoid anything that is a compound. > > > > "Ole Bob" > > > > Frank Key wrote: > > > > > Innovative Natural Products 500 ppm colloidal silver was submitted > for > > > analysis by a list member. > > > > > > The bottle identifies the product as being "colloidal silver" with > no > > > mention that it is silver protein. When the bottle is shaken it > foams > and > > > the foam persists for several minutes indicating that something > other > than > > > silver and water is present. This is typical of "silver protein" > products. > > > > > > Laboratory analysis indicates the product is a generic "silver > protein". > The > > > total silver concentration was measured to be 603 ppm. The silver > particles > > > are suspended in an aqueous animal protein solution (gelatin). > > > > > > For more details including the particle size distribution plot and > the > FT-IR > > > spectra plot see: > > > http://www.silver-colloids.com/Reports/cpr13/ > > > > > > frank key - Colloidal Science Lab. Inc. > > > > > > > -- > The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. > > Instructions for unsubscribing may be found at: http://silverlist.org > > To post, address your message to: [email protected] > > Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html > > List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>
