That is in vitro. We have already discussed that here and the opinion of those who analyzed it was that the protocol is flawed.
Basically he used a gel to test with, and it is well known that colloidal particles have no mobility and virtually no effect when in a gel. What is important is in vivo, and unless a person is made of gelatin, the study is not applicable to use in people. Since both silver compounds and colloidal silver eventually become the same thing in the blood stream, how could what you originally take make any difference except in the rate of absorption? There are studies that Frank Key has had done that were not flawed like this study and they show that both ionic as well as the colloidal component are germacidal as expected. Marshall Robert Berger wrote: > Jim, please go to www.natural-immunogenics.com, and look > around. Stephen recently had a in vitro test of his product and > Mesosilver after both had been innoculated with about 3 ppm of HCL to > eliminate the ionic portion of Mesosilver. It showed zero pathogenic > effect !!! Previously I had check Mesosilver at 4.5 PPM ionic. "Ole > Bob" > > Jim Holmes <[email protected]> wrote: > > Bob, > Are you saying only ionic Ag is effective? > Jim > >
