On 7/10/2020 7:20 AM, Johnny Billquist wrote:
On 2020-07-10 14:19, Paul Koning wrote:
On Jul 9, 2020, at 10:40 PM, Johnny Billquist <b...@softjar.se> wrote:
On 2020-07-10 04:37, Don North wrote:
On 7/9/2020 6:25 PM, Bob Supnik wrote:
Yes, the PDP11 Architecture Handbook was a post-facto effort. The J11 was
finished; DEC did not intend to do another PDP11 processor. (I wrote a
spec for one, primarily as an exercise in trying to do a different
microcode structure than the PLA/ROM of the LSI11/F11/J11, but I lost it.)
The only formal part of the PDP11 architecture was the Commercial
Instruction Set extension, DEC STD 168, which was only implemented by the
F11 and the 11/44.
AND the PDP-11/74 CIS option, I might add. Fully implemented, never sold.
Not to mention that the 11/74 in itself was fully implemented, but never
sold... Not even the 11/70MP...
Were there actually two prototypes called 11/74? I know the MP machine,
which the RSX-11 development team owned. And in Merrimack (home of RSTS and
some of the compiler teams) there was an 11/74 with CIS, for COBOL. But that
one wasn't an MP machine. Perhaps a coincidence, I don't have a real memory
either way.
Well, yes and no...
The PDP-11/70MP is a modified KB11-C. In the end it's really just a modified
11/70. There are changes to the microcode, and if I remember, a couple of
boards were changed. (See
http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/dec/pdp11/1174/EK-70MP-TM_PRE_1170mp_Prelim_Technical_Manual_1977.pdf).
The PDP-11/74 is the KB11-E. This was a more major redesign, which then
allowed for the addition of CIS. (See
http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/dec/pdp11/1174/Prelim_KB11-E_Diffs_Aug78.pdf).
But depending on what documentation you read, they might both be called 11/74.
Johnny
What Johnny said is basically correct. Way back then there were two separate
programs going on:
1) a research program led by Verell Boaen (IIRC) on turning a standard 11/70 in
an MP config. As indicated this required minor updates to the 11/70 microcode
(to make the ASRB instruction act as a hardware interlock) and the IIST board
for interprocessor communication. Multiport memory boxes also as I recall. This
project was termed '11/70-MP'.
2) a hardware program led by Dick Brown (IIRC) in PDP-11 engineering to add CIS
functionality to the 11/70 and update the CPU to what was called, then, the
11/74. Some changes to CPU microcode to support CIS instruction dispatch and
communication with the four board CIS processor. Changes to 11/70 backplane.
Changes to a few CPU modules (not many and not complex).
At some point the CPU microcode update for ASRB was folded into the 11/74 CPU
also, making it MP compatible.
I even have a plex of the updated 11/74 front panel I 'appropriated' when the
11/74 was canceled, Here is a scan:
https://www.ak6dn.com/stuff/1174.jpg
Ultimately DEC marketing canceled the 11/74 CIS. There have been arguments and
justifications over the years as to exactly why, but my communications with the
marketing folks at the time was that when benchmarking Cobol performance the
11/74 CIS significantly outperformed the 11/780 (which had just been released).
So marketing had a positioning problem and the solution was to kill the 11/74 in
favor of promoting the 11/780 family to eliminate the issue. Inarguably a wise
decision at the time as the VAX was to be the future of DEC. At least until Alpha...
The 11/44 had a parallel implementation of the same CIS architecture (in fact I
have an 11/44 with the hardware CIS option in my garage that is fully
functional. Sadly no 11/74 ...) but it was much lower in performance (and cost)
than the 11/74 CIS.
Don
DEC 11/74 microcode 1979-1980 or so
--
Don North
AK6DN
_______________________________________________
Simh mailing list
Simh@trailing-edge.com
http://mailman.trailing-edge.com/mailman/listinfo/simh
