Hi. Colleagues.

I am wondering about a trusted-UAC-behavior in relation to privacy.

7.2 Trusted UAC Behavior in privacy-04

step 1---- if the request is part of an existing dialog, and the request is sent 
directly to the UAS, 
                then the UAC MAY omit the calling subscriber Remote-Party-ID header
                :
step 2 ---- If the UAC desires privacy for the Remote-Party-ID header fields it added, 
it MUST          include an rpi-privacy parameter with each relevant Remote-Party-ID.
        

step 3 ---- If the UAC indicates "name" or "full" privacy (in either Remote-Party-ID 
or 
                RPID-Privacy), the UAC MUST NOT reveal....

step 4 ---- If the UAC desires "uri" or "full" privacy, the UAC MUST NOT reveal  the 
subscriber's               identity in any other header field than Remote-Party-ID.

If UAC omits the Calling subscriber Remote-Party-ID and don't include Remote-Party-ID 
according to step1 and step2 above, because the if-clause in step 3 and step4 is 
false(there isn't Remote-Party-ID and PRID-Privacy), step 3 and step 4  isn't applied 
to the request.

However, it is not what we want. even though the request is sent directly to the UAS 
and there isn't Remote-Party-ID and PRID-Privacy, if we want to provide privacy, step 
3 and step 4 MUST be applied.

so the solution that I think is to remove step 1 in draft or to always encrypts From , 
To, etc such as 3GPP.

how do you think about that?

Regards

j.m.jung





_______________________________________________
Sip-implementors mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.cs.columbia.edu/mailman/listinfo/sip-implementors

Reply via email to