Hi All,

My doubt is w.r.t MSRP

RFC 4975/4976 clearly mentions that if Initial *valid MSRP SEND *is received
at the relay with *Failure-Report *= *YES, *then the relay sends back final
response to the UE.

*A)** RFC 4976: Section 6.4.1 page 20 says:*
   If an incoming SEND request contains a Failure-Report header with a
   value of "yes", an MSRP relay that receives that SEND request MUST
   respond with a final response immediately.

However if a *valid Initial MSRP SEND *request is received by relay
with *Failure-Report
= Partial or No*, then what should Relay do?

I think we cannot consider that MSRP SEND comes in with Failure-Report = YES
as default value because

*B)**RFC 4975 : 5.3 page 10 says:*

   The Success-Report header field can have a value of "yes" or "no" and
   the Failure-Report header field can have a value of "yes", "no", or
   "partial".

If we logically take into account that if *valid Initial MSRP SEND *request
is received by relay with *Failure-Report =  No, *then we need no send any
response to it. And in case of *Partial *do we treat it as *YES* and send
back a final response to the sender of *MSRP SEND *message?


Thanks & Regards,
Vikas Jayaprakash
_______________________________________________
Sip-implementors mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.cs.columbia.edu/cucslists/listinfo/sip-implementors

Reply via email to