Marcos Dytz wrote:
>
> I agree on the limitations described below by Jeff. My concern was with
> the emphasis on authentication throughout the draft, but I had in mind
> that it was actually targeting that particular point (in the same way
> that sip-paying targets payment).
Ok.
> Nevertheless, are there ideas to develop new drafts on further cases for
> SIP/SAML?
Yes. Hannes has a few "in the queue".
> In my personal opinion, the protocol offers many technical
which protocol?
> advantages (and flexibilities) that could be required for more general
> use cases.
> By adopting and developing new cases, the overall protocol
> would only be gaining a larger market share and could very well adopt
> some synergy among the different areas.
here, by "..the overall protocol..", you mean "SIP+SAML"?
> As for Sebastian, I have the impression that he would like to see more
> integration and deployment details. I had problems to fulfill the gaps
> on integration while working on my thesis (e.g., enveloping SAML
> assertions in SIP message - usually workflows target the transaction
> state and avoid mentioning how to converge that with SIP - I did my
> implementation in the way I thought best, but every developer is free to
> choose different formats if specification does not define these little
> details).
But you weren't implementing what is specified in draft-ietf-sip-saml-02 were
you?
Do you have pointers to any documentation or papers about your work? Or the
code? :)
> As for your final points, agree to limitations due to complexity and
> partial fulfilment of RFC4484. If further work is to be applied on the
> draft, I believe the best action would be to leave the draft as it is
> and start another work from scratch.
Ok, fine by me.
thanks again for your feedback,
=JeffH
_______________________________________________
Sip mailing list https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/sip
This list is for NEW development of the core SIP Protocol
Use [EMAIL PROTECTED] for questions on current sip
Use [EMAIL PROTECTED] for new developments on the application of sip
