40 years after leak, the Pentagon Papers are out
by CALVIN WOODWARD and RICHARD LARDNER,
sfgate.com
June 13th 2011
(06-13) 16:43 PDT WASHINGTON, (AP) --
Call it the granddaddy of WikiLeaks. Four decades ago, a young defense
analyst leaked a top-secret study packed with damaging revelations about
America's conduct of the Vietnam War.
On Monday, that study, dubbed the Pentagon Papers, finally came out in
complete form. It's a touchstone for whistleblowers everywhere and just the
sort of leak that gives presidents fits to this day.
The documents show that almost from the opening lines, it was apparent that
the authors knew they had produced a hornet's nest.
In his Jan. 15, 1969, confidential memorandum introducing the report to the
defense chief, the chairman of the task force that produced the study hinted
at the explosive nature of the contents. "Writing history, especially where
it blends into current events, especially where that current event is
Vietnam, is a treacherous exercise," Leslie H. Gelb wrote.
Asked by Defense Secretary Robert S. McNamara to do an "encyclopedic and
objective" study of U.S. involvement in Vietnam from World War II to 1967,
the team of three dozen analysts pored over a trove of Pentagon, CIA and
State Department documents with "ant-like diligence," he wrote.
Their work revealed a pattern of deception by the Lyndon Johnson, John
Kennedy and prior administrations as they secretly escalated the conflict
while assuring the public that, in Johnson's words, the U.S. did not seek a
wider war.
The National Archives released the Pentagon Papers in full Monday and put
them online, long after most of the secrets spilled. The release was timed
40 years to the day after The New York Times published the first in its
series of stories about the findings, on June 13, 1971, prompting President
Richard Nixon to try to suppress publication and crush anyone in government
who dared to spill confidences.
Prepared near the end of Johnson's term by Defense Department and private
analysts, the report was leaked primarily by one of them, Daniel Ellsberg,
in a brash act of defiance that stands as one of the most dramatic episodes
of whistleblowing in U.S. history.
As scholars pore over the 47-volume report, Ellsberg said the chance of them
finding great new revelations is dim. Most of it has come out in
congressional forums and by other means, and Ellsberg plucked out the best
when he painstakingly photocopied pages that he spirited from a safe night
after night, and returned in the mornings.
He told The Associated Press the value in Monday's release was in having the
entire study finally brought together and put online, giving today's
generations ready access to it.
The Pentagon Papers chronicle failures of U.S. policy at seemingly every
turn. One was a focused attempt from 1961 to 1963 to pacify rural Vietnam
with the Strategic Hamlet Program, combining military operations to secure
villages with construction, economic aid and resettlement.
The report concludes the U.S. had not learned lessons of the past, namely
that peasants would resist attempts to change their lives. The hamlet
program "was fatally flawed in its conception by the unintended consequence
of alienating many of those whose loyalty it aimed to win," it said.
At the time, Nixon was delighted that people were reading about bumbling and
lies by his predecessors, which he thought would take some anti-war heat off
him. But if he loved the substance of the leak, he hated the leaker.
He called the leak an act of treachery and vowed that the people behind it
"have to be put to the torch." He feared that Ellsberg represented a
left-wing cabal that would undermine his own administration with damaging
disclosures if the government did not make him an example for all others
with loose lips.
It was his belief in such a conspiracy, and his willingness to combat it by
illegal means, that put him on the path to the Watergate scandal that
destroyed his presidency.
Original Page:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2011/06/12/national/w201515D
94.DTL
Shared from Read It Later
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Sixties-L" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.com/group/sixties-l?hl=en.
