It could be a side effect of the fix for 6465359 "Exclusion dependencies could make svcadm milestone spin" that was integrated in s10u5. Anyway, I suggest you call Sun Service so they can evaluate the problem for Solaris 10.
-- Renaud Ashish Kulshrestha wrote: > Yes it is reproducible with stop/start exec methods also.This > service which is online is not attempted to be disabled (temporarily) by > svc.startd deamon when shutdown command is given. It is behaving in such > manner in solariss 10 update 5 but this scenario works fine in solaris > 10 update 3. > > ~Ashish > > > On 6/10/08, *Renaud Manus* <Renaud.Manus at sun.com > <mailto:Renaud.Manus at sun.com>> wrote: > > Your services don't have exec methods. Can you still reproduce it > with the mandatory start/stop exec methods ? > > -- Renaud > > Ashish Kulshrestha wrote: > > Hi David > I got an issue in the solaris 10 update 5 in shutdown in > stopping the services which are "exclude_all" dependent. > Steps to reproduce : > 1.create a file /A.xml : > ===================================== > <?xml version="1.0"?> > <!DOCTYPE service_bundle SYSTEM > "/usr/share/lib/xml/dtd/service_bundle.dtd.1"> > <service_bundle type='manifest' name='A'> > <service > name='A' > type='service' > version='1'> > <single_instance /> > <dependency > name='A_exclude_B' > type='service' > grouping='exclude_all' > restart_on='refresh'> > <service_fmri value='svc:/B' /> > </dependency> > <property_group name='startd' type='framework'> > <propval name='duration' type='astring' > value='transient' /> > </property_group> > <instance name='default' enabled='false' /> > <template> > <common_name> > <loctext xml:lang='C'> > A service > </loctext> > </common_name> > </template> > </service> > </service_bundle> > =============================================== > 2. create another file /B.xml > =============================================== > <?xml version="1.0"?> > <!DOCTYPE service_bundle SYSTEM > "/usr/share/lib/xml/dtd/service_bundle.dtd.1"> > <service_bundle type='manifest' name='B'> > <service > name='B' > type='service' > version='1'> > <single_instance /> > <property_group name='startd' type='framework'> > <propval name='duration' type='astring' > value='transient' /> > </property_group> > <instance name='default' enabled='false' /> > <template> > <common_name> > <loctext xml:lang='C'> > B service > </loctext> > </common_name> > </template> > </service> > </service_bundle> > ======================================================== > 3. svccfg import /A.xml > 4. svccfg import /B.xml > 5. svcadm enable A > 6. svcadm enable B > 7.shutdown -i6 -g5 -y > It hangs the system.If I login to the machine before giving > shutdown command through ssh it shows me that the service "B" is > online with the only service > "svc:/system/svc/restarter:default". This behaviour can not be > reproduced in the Solaris 10 update 3. > Thanks and regards, > Ashish Kulshrestha > > > On 6/9/08, *David Bustos* <David.Bustos at sun.com > <mailto:David.Bustos at sun.com> <mailto:David.Bustos at sun.com > <mailto:David.Bustos at sun.com>>> wrote: > > Quoth Ashish Kulshrestha on Mon, Jun 09, 2008 at 09:28:20PM > +0530: > > online.As soon as I disabled it the shutdown which was > hanged is > resumed. I > > have to use dependent tag in my manifest file as the > dependency > tag is > > not starting my service at a particular milestone using > the "*boot -m > > milestone=multi-user*" from ok prompt. > > Did you try booting without -m milestone=multi-user, or with > "-m milestone=all"? > > > My question : > > Is SMF framework wont issue any command to stop the service in > graceful > > shutdown ? Is it just stops the milestone and rest is > taken care > by order of > > dependency of services ? > > What happen if a service is isolated ( no dependent or > dependency in > > manifest file). > > svc.startd should temporarily disable the services which have no > dependents by executing their stop methods. As each service > is stopped, > it should again temporarily disable the services which have no > dependents, until all services are stopped. > > Did you make sure that the system was finished booting (svcs > didn't > report any services with asterisks after their state) before > executing > shutdown? > > > David > > > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > _______________________________________________ > smf-discuss mailing list > smf-discuss at opensolaris.org <mailto:smf-discuss at opensolaris.org> > > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > _______________________________________________ > smf-discuss mailing list > smf-discuss at opensolaris.org
