Interesting thought.  But, a lot of what I'm writing
about concerns asynchronous communication.  For
example, the book contains code snippets that show how
to run SOAP over MQSeries using both the Java for MQ
classes and the MQ implementation of JMS.  The reason
to run SOAP over a MOM product
like MQ is to ensure reliability and fault tolerance
(vs. HTTP).Interestingly, with Apache SOAP 2.2, you
can implement a MessageRouter and deploy web services
without using HTTP.  This is important to the audience
my book is targeting, because EAI solutions have to
deal with situations where services go down, networks
go down, etc.  The required fault tolerance is not
available via HTTP.

Would you say that AXIS is as robust at SOAP 2.2 in
this regard?

Mark Hansen
bus tel:  888-360-7285
bus fax:  914-723-8671
email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

-----Original Message-----
From: Sam Ruby [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
Sent: Friday, February 08, 2002 1:28 PM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: SOAP 2.2 vs. AXIS


Mark Hansen wrote:
>
> I'm writing a book on how to use SOAP, Web Services,
> and Java to implement Enterprise Application
> Integration (EAI).
>
> I've been writing all code examples in the book
using
> the Apache SOAP 2.2 implementation.  However, now I
> see SOAP books coming out that use AXIS rather than
> the older SOAP 2.2 code.
>
> Question:  Should I use SOAP 2.2 or AXIS for the
code
> examples in my book??
>
> Anyone and everyone with an opinion is invited to
> respond to this message.  It is really important to
me
> to get a sense of what the SOAP/Java community is
> doing.

In my opinion, you should consider basing your
examples on JAX RPC
(http://java.sun.com/xml/jaxrpc/), which Apache Axis
implements directly.
There was a time when every vendor by necessity had to
create their own
API.  Now we are trying to move towards a point in
time where at least the
Java vendors have implement a common API.

- Sam Ruby


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Send FREE Valentine eCards with Yahoo! Greetings!
http://greetings.yahoo.com

Reply via email to