|
A point that has been overlooked in the skeg rule discussion for rudder/elevator/spoiler airplanes is that if skegs are outlawed, designers will find a way around the rule. The optimum duration sailplane fuselage might feature a drooped forward fuselage that aligns with the upwash flow into the wing. The aft fuselage might also droop to align with the downwash. These angles are on the order of several degrees at thermalling speeds. There is a serious landing problem with the drooped nose. If the model lands straight and just a little hot it tends to bounce back up. If it lands a little hot in a crosswind, the yaw moment imparted by the ground on the nose both bounces the airplane and yaws it at the same time. If the model has ample dihedral, this action can result in a rapid and uncontrollable roll followed by an immediate inverted collision with the ground. Hobie Hawks are well known for this behavior. The drooped nose is a problem even for the most perfect landing. When the model is sliding on the ground the wing is at an angle that produces substantial lift. This reduces the friction with the ground and the model slides a long way. This is like putting on a fast green � accuracy is reduced. One solution is to mount a skeg behind the center of gravity. Touching down on the skeg pitches the airplane down, reducing lift, increasing friction and shortening the skid. It also tends to straighten the model out in a crosswind landing, a possible advantage. In any case, the Hobie Hawk flip is eliminated. A skeg would be an excellent improvement to the Hobie Hawk. Another solution is to reshape the fuselage so that it has a deep belly that bottoms out aft of the CG. If this belly starts from a high nose, the model is able to touch down aft of the CG and pitch down. This can have essentially the same function as the skeg. Mark Smith did this with his popular and successful "Windfree" design from the mid-1970�s. Shaping this belly so that it is aerodynamically clean is a challenge for the designer. Shaping it so that it is aesthetically pleasing is a greater challenge! Outlawing this shaping may be challenging for the rules-makers, but as long as great emphasis is placed on landing scores, the designers will find a way. Lastly, a simple solution is to mount the wing at a lower incidence angle on the fuselage. This causes the fuselage to touch down on the aft fuselage or tail, and reduces the lift during the skid. Of course, the model will thermal with the fuselage pointing nose-up. This is not too pretty, in my estimation. For my money, the skeg is the most effective, aesthetic and aerodynamic solution to the problem. It also protects the bottom of the fuselage on hard or abrasive fields. I suggest permitting the best solution to the problem as opposed to forcing a second-best solution on the competitors. Blaine Beron-Rawdon 1/27/00 |
Title: Skeg Rules for RES Sailplanes

